This is a paywall article, so I’ll also include a link to a few skeets from John Hudson one of the writers at the end of this submission statement.
According to WaPo sources, Iran is going to be able to hold out economically for at least another 3-4 months. Along with retaining a huge majority of its pre-war missiles and launchers. US leadership has tried to claim otherwise, but as peace looms it would seem they’re acknowledging this.
I posted this elsewhere but it really is confusing how no one said „hey you know every simulation we’ve ever run has found it incredibly difficult to keep the straits open“ maybe they did and we’re fired.
It leaves another question though what did the admin expect to happen here? I am very confused as to what they thought the sequence of events would look like in their heads.
BluishHope on
They can, if they go full scorched earth on themselves (which is something the regime is seemingly ready, or even wants, to do).
However, this also increases friction with the population who got nothing to lose, diminishing assets, and accruing damages it will take them decades to recover.
They’re losing a lot of power and influence by the day, and are basically running like the Houthi occupied Yemen now. Not a big achievement. Disrupt trade and be a pain in the ass for the world, while the leaders are hunkering in bunkers or going out only when surrounded by so many civilians the western powers would consider as too much collateral damage.
It’s surviving, but not really living.
Gerbole on
I don’t really buy this. Iran runs out of oil storage in the next 10-14 days. China just told its banks to pause loans on sanctioned refineries. I buy that they still have a large supply of drones but I am unsure they have a “majority” of their missiles and launchers. I’m not sure what else we would be attacking, and we know they don’t have a very great air defense system.
The economy has been crumbling for a while and was at a breaking point before the war. I really don’t see how they could be expected to last 4 months when they have literally no economy left. Just the objective fact that they import basically all of their *food’s* food alone makes me question this report.
I have no doubt Iran is doing better than Trump says, but I seriously doubt Iran is fairly unscathed and has a lot more fight in them like this article seems to suggest. No money, no food. No one lasts 4 months with those 2 things in play.
Edit: Imports 80% of their livestock feed*
Chanan-Ben-Zev on
Okay, so the timeline for achieving regime change is measured in months and not years. Why is this being paraded about as a grand indictment against the war effort?
Berliner1220 on
Outlast means what exactly?
yeeeter1 on
>Iran can outlast Trump’s blockade for months
I’m not sure this is a proper use of the word outlast
Dark1000 on
That’s actually a pretty damning outlook for Iran. If they can only last 3-4 months under the most desperate circumstances, it means that there’s (1) an end point in sight and (2) that endpoint is rapidly approaching.
DancingFlame321 on
If you look through the history of sanctioning and blockading rogue regimes like Cuba or North Korea, usually the effect embargoes have in these countries isn’t causing regime change to a more Western friendly government.
Usually what happens is that the original regime desperately clings onto power, whilst the life for the average citizen living there becomes absolutely miserable. It turns out starving people with no guns don’t make for great rebels.
Ok_Breakfast4482 on
I mean Afghanistan and Vietnam both outlasted the US for over 20 years and both of those wars had US ground troops (which there won’t be in Iran) so yeah I have no problem believing Iran can hold out for a few months. We’ve been fairly delusional in the US for a long time about our ability to win wars in the middle and far east.
manniesalado on
Iran is getting help from many. Trump is getting help from no one.
stickybond009 on
Just in: The US struck military targets in Iran after the country fired on three Navy destroyers sailing in the Strait of Hormuz, an escalation that threatened to break apart a fragile ceasefire and reignite hostilities even as the two sides say they’re discussing an end to the war.
“Just like we knocked them out again today, we’ll knock them out a lot harder, and a lot more violently, in the future, if they don’t get their Deal signed, FAST!” President Donald Trump said in a social media post.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
12 Kommentare
This is a paywall article, so I’ll also include a link to a few skeets from John Hudson one of the writers at the end of this submission statement.
According to WaPo sources, Iran is going to be able to hold out economically for at least another 3-4 months. Along with retaining a huge majority of its pre-war missiles and launchers. US leadership has tried to claim otherwise, but as peace looms it would seem they’re acknowledging this.
https://bsky.app/profile/johnphudson.bsky.social/post/3mlbjn7n76a22
[don’t make me tap the sign](https://i.imgur.com/Rk9jIIz.png)
I posted this elsewhere but it really is confusing how no one said „hey you know every simulation we’ve ever run has found it incredibly difficult to keep the straits open“ maybe they did and we’re fired.
It leaves another question though what did the admin expect to happen here? I am very confused as to what they thought the sequence of events would look like in their heads.
They can, if they go full scorched earth on themselves (which is something the regime is seemingly ready, or even wants, to do).
However, this also increases friction with the population who got nothing to lose, diminishing assets, and accruing damages it will take them decades to recover.
They’re losing a lot of power and influence by the day, and are basically running like the Houthi occupied Yemen now. Not a big achievement. Disrupt trade and be a pain in the ass for the world, while the leaders are hunkering in bunkers or going out only when surrounded by so many civilians the western powers would consider as too much collateral damage.
It’s surviving, but not really living.
I don’t really buy this. Iran runs out of oil storage in the next 10-14 days. China just told its banks to pause loans on sanctioned refineries. I buy that they still have a large supply of drones but I am unsure they have a “majority” of their missiles and launchers. I’m not sure what else we would be attacking, and we know they don’t have a very great air defense system.
The economy has been crumbling for a while and was at a breaking point before the war. I really don’t see how they could be expected to last 4 months when they have literally no economy left. Just the objective fact that they import basically all of their *food’s* food alone makes me question this report.
I have no doubt Iran is doing better than Trump says, but I seriously doubt Iran is fairly unscathed and has a lot more fight in them like this article seems to suggest. No money, no food. No one lasts 4 months with those 2 things in play.
Edit: Imports 80% of their livestock feed*
Okay, so the timeline for achieving regime change is measured in months and not years. Why is this being paraded about as a grand indictment against the war effort?
Outlast means what exactly?
>Iran can outlast Trump’s blockade for months
I’m not sure this is a proper use of the word outlast
That’s actually a pretty damning outlook for Iran. If they can only last 3-4 months under the most desperate circumstances, it means that there’s (1) an end point in sight and (2) that endpoint is rapidly approaching.
If you look through the history of sanctioning and blockading rogue regimes like Cuba or North Korea, usually the effect embargoes have in these countries isn’t causing regime change to a more Western friendly government.
Usually what happens is that the original regime desperately clings onto power, whilst the life for the average citizen living there becomes absolutely miserable. It turns out starving people with no guns don’t make for great rebels.
I mean Afghanistan and Vietnam both outlasted the US for over 20 years and both of those wars had US ground troops (which there won’t be in Iran) so yeah I have no problem believing Iran can hold out for a few months. We’ve been fairly delusional in the US for a long time about our ability to win wars in the middle and far east.
Iran is getting help from many. Trump is getting help from no one.
Just in: The US struck military targets in Iran after the country fired on three Navy destroyers sailing in the Strait of Hormuz, an escalation that threatened to break apart a fragile ceasefire and reignite hostilities even as the two sides say they’re discussing an end to the war.
“Just like we knocked them out again today, we’ll knock them out a lot harder, and a lot more violently, in the future, if they don’t get their Deal signed, FAST!” President Donald Trump said in a social media post.