Close Menu
    Karten

    Premierminister vs. Präsident: Wer hat die Exekutivgewalt?

    Share.
    View 43 Comments

    43 Kommentare

    1. sambare on

      Might wanna either exclude monarquies or change „president“ to something more comprehensive

    2. monsterfurby on

      Is this about the literal title „Prime Minister“, because Germany and Austria, which have a parliament-elected head of the executive, have no reason to be grey here other than that.

    3. confidentlyfish on

      The President of the Russian Federation doesn’t hold the executive power. It is a position above the three branches which acts as a guarantor of the Constitution. The Chairman of the Government (Prime-Minister inbefore) is the head of the Executive branch.

      This map is blatantly false.

    6. MentirosoProfesional on

      In chile is def not the president

      Our last three presidents were subservient to their „prime ministers“ or what we call „ministro de hacienda“

      Our actual president is Jose Antonio kast, but it is clear to everyone that the guy in charge is Quiroz, not kast.

    10. pickledegg1989 on

      Chancellor is just a fancy name for the German/Austrian Prime Minister, like Taoiseach in Ireland.

    11. determineduncertain on

      Yeah, Australia, Canada, and New Zealand are all parliamentary democracies with the executive power vested in the sovereign, not the PM.

    12. azhder on

      In some places it isn either-or, but then again, we have seen this post before, can’t expect the 1% top poster post something original

    13. TENTAtheSane on

      Wrong for india at least. Prime minister wields legislative power, but president holds executive power

    14. Commagenes on

      Regarding Serbia – it varies depending on what role Aleksandar Vucic holds at the moment of the analysis. De jure, per Constitution, it is the PM. De facto, it is AV.

    15. girlofy on

      The real issue is that „Prime Minister“ and „President“ aren’t consistent titles across systems—monarchies and ceremonial presidencies muddy the comparison. Better to separate parliamentary from presidential systems entirely than argue over who’s technically a PM.

    16. Randomizedname1234 on

      In the USA it’s Israel so it should be PM since Benjamin Fuckface a prime minister?

    19. Usagi-Zakura on

      Find it kinda funny to have monarchy nations marked as blue… its true, the Prime Minister holds more power…because there’s no President :p

    22. Dealiner on

      In Poland executive power is exercised by the president and the council of ministers, led by the prime minister, so both colours are valid.

    23. TheSpiritKnight on

      Yeah no the map is flat-out wrong. Romania is a semi-presidential republic, executive power is divided between the president and the prime minister.

    24. Ok_Income_2173 on

      Why are Germany and Austria not blue? In both cases executive power lies withthe chancellor and that is just another word for PM basically.

    27. Mroogal on

      Poland should be gray. Prime minister holds most of the powers, but president has veto power over parliament, so… polish politics is now a clusterfuck as both of them are from different political parties. Welcome to permanent constitutional crisis 🙂

    30. TomiRey-Yuru on

      France is wrong… As a semi-presidential republic, sure, the president holds many powers, but the PM is still the head of the government.

    31. razvanmg15 on

      The executive power in Romania is held by the prime minister, who leads the government, not by the president.

    32. jerome_morgan on

      Romania should have been blue honestly, president has more external attributes while the PM is the head of the executive.

    33. tanhan27 on

      Technically incorrect, for many constitutional monarchys, such as Canada, the Monarch holds executive power.

    35. Username1213141 on

      Romanian President is not an executive, the President appoints the executive – Prime Minister – which then will be voted with his team of Ministers in the Parliament

    37. thepinkfluffy1211 on

      France and Romania are semi-presidential republics. It is incorrect to state, that the president holds executive power. The president’s only ‚executive power‘ derives from the fact that he gets to appoint the PM, which then has to be approved by the government.

    40. Denova_Vendetta on

      In Germany, it’s the Chancellor who holds the executive power. And the Federal President of Germany is Symbolic, Ceremonial and a Constitutional figure. Has no executive power.

    41. Icy-Response6124 on

      The position of Chancellor in Germany is the same as that of Prime Minister in the rest of the parliamentary republics and monarchies, therefore Germany should be in blue.

      Regardless, if I had to choose between a presidential, semi-presidential, or parliamentary system, I would choose the parliamentary one, because the task of creating a „buffoon dictator who can cover up his oligarchy“ is more difficult than with the other two systems. Not impossible, but difficult.

    42. Dom_Salvatore on

      Presidente não tem poder nenhum em democracias com forte oposição no congresso (senadores e deputados).

    43. usernameisokay_ on

      In the Netherlands it’s not the prime minister and we don’t have a president, it’s the king that holds the power.

    Leave A Reply