Die Labour-Partei steht vor einer katastrophalen Kommunalwahl im Mai und wird voraussichtlich 1.850 Sitze verlieren, prognostiziert ein Experte
https://www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/news/uk-news/may-local-elections-labour-council-33862950#google_vignette
Von Desperate-Drawer-572
26 Kommentare
Is anyone else in the position of having no positive feelings towards Keir Starmer in particular, but still thinking that it’s absolute bullshit how people are reacting to his tenure and that almost every opposing party would be much worse to have in government?
I’ve never known local elections not be a disaster for the government.
Course man they are still trying to be too many things to too many people, how can you possibly reconcile politically the patriotic, anti immigration and often rural working class white vote with the „Muslim vote“ and the urban progressives.
That is exactly why they are losing voters like a sieve to both Greens and Reform, both extremes appeal socially to fundamentally incompatible groups, you can’t just sit in the middle, ultimately pleasing nobody and hope they don’t notice.
How many seats are having elections? 1850 sounds like a lot (and it is) but context is nice to have.
And also who are they expected to lose them too? If its mostly Lib Dems or Greens then thats a win in my mind, if its mostly Reform then that a huge lose.
-edit-
Its out of 2,557. Ouch.
Greens gain 500
Lib Dems gain 150
Tories lose 600
Reform gain 1500
Part of me thinks this might be good if it shows people how utterly fucking disastrous Reform will be at governing local councils, that there’s no way they can govern a full country.
It’s wild watching people act like Starmer’s Labour is the exact same disaster as the Tories, when the reality is that the opposition is a dumpster fire and the media can’t stop hammering the „both sides“ narrative. Yeah, he’s not exciting, but I’d take boring over whatever the alternative is right now.
the day after, having lost 1,849, the various labour shills will be screaming they did far better than expected
There’s plenty not to like about Keir’s government. But these are local elections, and anyone elected will be expected to work on local issues. People shouldn’t be treating it like a referendum.
Locally, I’m in an area that has been solidly tory for centuries, but is currently a tosser between tory and refuk. No other parties stand a chance. Despite my left-leaning politics, I would actually vote tory to prevent refuk getting in. That is both an artefact of the constituency boundary divisions and a flaw in the first-past-the-post voting system.
Edit: Just to clarify, I dislike the tories. I dislike refuk too. But for all their flaws, tory councillors can at least show up to work and run a council somewhat competently, albeit with varying levels of corruption. Something like 10% of elected refuk councillors have quit since they were elected, which is a crazy high number to quit before their elected term is up. That’s not even addressing the chronic absenteeism among elected refuk councillors. Whether you agree or disagree with their politics, the most basic function of an elected representative is to show up to debates and vote.
In a general election, I would not vote for them, because even „wasted“ votes are still counted for the purpose of distributing parliamentary funding — the so-called „short money“. (This is how the LibDems have been able to consistently have a presence above their apparent number of MPs.)
[https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01663/](https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn01663/)
i look at all available alternatives and i will probably be voting labour
What’s insane is I know so many who voted for Boris and never talked much shit about him even after partgate and clear covid scandals surrounding that party.
Same people can not stop moaning about how bad Starmer is.
I’m voting labour because they are the best of a bad bunch. Conservatives have fucked us for years and reform is full of bigots and grifters. Greens are little too populist for my taste and Lib Dem’s feels like a wasted vote. Starmers record is unremarkable but it’s not a catastrophe like truss Johnson etc
Not a surprise, I voted for them because they promised to end the „feudal leasehold system“ as in their program, not patches, but an end to it. Still waiting.
Starmer is a spectacular authoritarian. He’s restricted freedom in every way he can. Silenced protest, banned porn that harms no one, brought in age checks, banned cigarettes, continues to ban cannabis despite a reality of it being widely used and normal.
I simply cannot vote for a party that do these things. The tories are just as bad of course but I will not vote for the Labour Party that thinks it can tell me what to do this much.
How are people stupid enough to vote reform. Blows my mind.
I’m all for a protest vote against Labour to nudge them in the right direction, I just don’t trust them to take the right lessons from defeat.
Yeah, their promise of “slow decline under us followed by rapid decline when we hand back to the Tories” isn’t resonating any more. We need radical change. If Labour won’t do it, then maybe we do need Reform and the Greens to break the system so that we have no choice but to rebuild from scratch.
Well they won a free election and proceeded to piss off almost every voter group. Attempted to cut pension fuel allowance, talk of benefit cuts, increase in business taxes, increase in personal taxes and cost of living (tax free allowance freeze, council tax, water rate increase exc) and are forcing through digital ID and online safety regardless of the pushback. I can’t think of any demographic that doesn’t have a reason to be annoyed….
Im glad to see this happening, labour isn’t labour anymore and I’m tired of people pretending it is, I tired of this false narrative that labour is bringing the nhs waiting list down or labour is helping the job market or peoe get back into work, they aren’t, if you’ve engaged with any of these services they’re getting worse, especially when it comes to mental health. It has taken years for me to get assessed and diagnosed with autism adhd and cptsd, I have to wait 18 months or more for a Endoscopy for suspected asophagitis. I spoke to a psychiatrist for the first time just weeks ago and while they are willing to support me whilst we wait for a decision on psychological support they informed me that the waiting list doesn’t exist anymore they’re too stretched and my referral will likely be declined again. I’m sick, and sick of it and the hate that people in my position receive because of this government and media and seemingly a lot of uninformed or unaffected people have.
Starmer’s biggest problem is that he can’t see the optics of his decisions. He’s so obsessed with process that he doesn’t account for the human factor.
Look at the Grooming Gang enquiry. He resisted a national enquiry. How did he think that would make Labour look? If he had simply agreed to one in the first instance then it would have shown strong leadership.
Going for the old folk with the Winter Fuel allowance. Out of all the people he could hammer he chose the pensioners. Why?
He just isn’t a very good leader. I believe he’s very easily led and looks uncomfortable when dealing with other members of the human race.
Still, he’s a cat lover so he’s not all bad.
Here’s some Labour successes:
* Hereditary peers in the house of lords, very unpopular with the public. Abolished.
* Remember those „non-doms“ that were a big deal under Blair and subsequent governments? The rich foreigners who live here but pay no tax because they declare themselves as foreign residents and their income as foreign income? Abolished by Labour.
* Incorporated „Great British Energy“ – a publicly-owned energy provider specialising in clean energy production and delivery. Not due to start delivering energy yet, but implementation in progress.
* Closed the loophole that allowed private schools to avoid paying tax.
* Introduced the Water Special Measures Act, allowing water company executives to be held criminally liable for obstructing investigations into water pollution incidents.
* Introduced a lot of new rights for tenants. Banned no-fault evictions. Landlords must advertise the real rental price and may not accept bidding wars. Rents can only be increased in line with market rates.
* Huge improvements to worker’s rights: banned zero-hours contracts; banned fire-and-rehire; unfair dismissal protection from 6 months instead of 2 years; maternity and paternity leave available from day 1; sick pay available to low-paid workers, removing the earnings threshold; repealed the tories‘ strike-busting act.
* Drastic reduction in immigration (https://www.reuters.com/world/uk/uk-lowers-population-growth-estimate-immigration-slows-2026-04-28/)
These are just the ones that can be found with a quick google. I think there are a lot more wins with regards to renewable energy, for example.
It’s hard not to conclude that Labour are actually doing a cracking job.
The Tory/reform bots are winning on social media for sure. Thankfully at least bots cannot vote
[deleted]
This is what happens when you get all of your information from social media and other echo chambers. I’m not a Starmer fan, however, his government has done some great work that needs to be highlighted more.
Historically I’ve voted Labour but this May I’m going to have to vote for Plaid Cymru to try and stave off Reform.
If I could vote for who I want it would have been Labour.
This is the Government that means I can’t see Imgur, who want to block my access to the Internet even further unless I jump through their hoops, thats letting my local council raise taxes again while providing less.
Sure tge Torries would have been just as bad, but don’t expect me to eat crap, cause the other option back then was crap.
Strange how moving far to the right when the public wanted you to move to the left can backfire.