This map is extremely wrong, it also rules out any Indo-European language that coexists with another of a different family
(for example basque and Spanish, or English in Alaska, or French in Quebec, or Spanish in Equatorial Guinea and you keep on naming places for a while)
If you spoke English in any place in Alaska, they are gonna understand you and talk to you in English, so the map doesn’t represent the distribution correctly there, for example
TimmyB52 on
There’s Hungary!
Fun_Examination_8343 on
Debatable map
Saturn--O-- on
Quebec?
PandaPlastic9371 on
This is innacurate, European languages often coexist with local tongues. (ex: Hong Kong, Nigeria, India, Malaysia, the Philippines)
AsemicConjecture on
I feel like there’s a lot of red missing in Africa.
mountaineer_93 on
Not bad for some boys from the Caspian steppe
KairosGalvanized on
is there a population amount required? because while not big cities there are small rural towns in the grey areas of Australia.
denn23rus on
What’s happening to the map of Russia? 98.5% of Siberia’s population speaks only Russian as their primary language.
Solafuge on
English is way more widespread than that through a good portion of Afica.
jubtheprophet on
This is like, shockingly bad. What metric could this possibly be using for what is or isnt red?
hesitantly-adamant on
Although the Indonesian language is not Indo-European, many of the local languages–which for a significant number of people are their first–are rooted in Sanskrit, which is one.
Lord-Glorfindel on
These maps always understate the expanse of actual majority languages in favour of nearly extinct and very rare minority indigenous languages. In Canada, this map has both Montréal and Québec City as not speaking French and The Yukon and Northern BC not speaking English. Somehow Townsville and Cairns in Australia have forgotten English. By some inverse miracle, the city of Cancun in Mexico has also forgotten Spanish and the city of Magadan in Russia has forgotten Russian.
gough_whitlam on
99% of Australia should be red.
Kallassoppin on
This map is overestimating the native languages of the Americas by quite a lot.
At least for Brazil, Portuguese is the mother language for 99% of the population.
Mushroomburger on
Shouldn’t Malta be gray instead of red? Unless we’re assuming everybody speaks English there.
OathofBling on
Would you like some PIE with that?
donaudampfschifffahr on
Oh yeah i forgot no one speaks english in Cairns thats right
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
18 Kommentare
This map is extremely wrong, it also rules out any Indo-European language that coexists with another of a different family
(for example basque and Spanish, or English in Alaska, or French in Quebec, or Spanish in Equatorial Guinea and you keep on naming places for a while)
If you spoke English in any place in Alaska, they are gonna understand you and talk to you in English, so the map doesn’t represent the distribution correctly there, for example
There’s Hungary!
Debatable map
Quebec?
This is innacurate, European languages often coexist with local tongues. (ex: Hong Kong, Nigeria, India, Malaysia, the Philippines)
I feel like there’s a lot of red missing in Africa.
Not bad for some boys from the Caspian steppe
is there a population amount required? because while not big cities there are small rural towns in the grey areas of Australia.
What’s happening to the map of Russia? 98.5% of Siberia’s population speaks only Russian as their primary language.
English is way more widespread than that through a good portion of Afica.
This is like, shockingly bad. What metric could this possibly be using for what is or isnt red?
Although the Indonesian language is not Indo-European, many of the local languages–which for a significant number of people are their first–are rooted in Sanskrit, which is one.
These maps always understate the expanse of actual majority languages in favour of nearly extinct and very rare minority indigenous languages. In Canada, this map has both Montréal and Québec City as not speaking French and The Yukon and Northern BC not speaking English. Somehow Townsville and Cairns in Australia have forgotten English. By some inverse miracle, the city of Cancun in Mexico has also forgotten Spanish and the city of Magadan in Russia has forgotten Russian.
99% of Australia should be red.
This map is overestimating the native languages of the Americas by quite a lot.
At least for Brazil, Portuguese is the mother language for 99% of the population.
Shouldn’t Malta be gray instead of red? Unless we’re assuming everybody speaks English there.
Would you like some PIE with that?
Oh yeah i forgot no one speaks english in Cairns thats right