It’s not like I want to advocate for processed foods, though you would be surprised how not-shelf-stable most things are. But this:
>David Kessler: Pick up any one of these products. You ever look at the– the ingredient label?
>Bill Whitaker: A lot of ‚em are things I can’t even pronounce.
>David Kessler: Right. Is that food? Corn syrup, corn solids, maltodextrin, dextrose, xylose, high-fructose corn syrup. And then these ingredients were subjected to industrial processing so that our system can’t handle it.
this is facebook grandma logic.
Skraelings on
wasnt intended for my body to travel at 70mph either, yet in a car I do that every day.
accountabilitycounts on
So are you going to regulate it?
Romantic_Piscean on
I mean, we could also break down corn, for example, into its various chemical components and make it sound frightening. The issue isn’t the stabilizing additives, it’s that we’ve trained our collective tastebuds and corporate food delivers for it.
But when Democrats talked about limiting the size of sodas, these same chuckleheads melted down. Now if they want to make good foods affordable instead of cheap calories, wonderful. But this ain’t that.
Bakedads on
Survival of the unfittest
GrumpyOldDad65 on
Yep. My body has been telling me that exact thing the past two weeks. Sucks. I love me some ultra processed food.
PhotonArmy on
Water toxemia is a real thing and a 35 year old mother died in 2023 simply by drinking too much water on vacation, causing her brain to swell.
… but try living without it.
Queasy-Deer-3591 on
Wasn’t RFK Jr supposed to clean up the food supply?
zirky on
we weren’t designed for extreme nacho flavor
we had to evolve for extreme nacho flavor
mok000 on
Well, biology, or rather biochemistry, can handle ultra processed food, but you will become sick over time from the high levels glucose and fructose they contain.
twitch_delta_blues on
So we should improve school lunches? Make fresh food more available to poor people? Fill in food deserts?
EvenSpoonier on
This is not a scientific argument. Do better.
Baron-Munc on
I blame the Great Depression and WW2
BronzeRider on
Spoken like a guy who doesn’t even have a high school level understanding of evolutionary biology.
“Never intended to handle”. That’s not even the right framing. Because clearly the human body CAN handle processed foods. It has been doing so for literal decades. And nothing in human evolution is “intended” for anything. It has functions, not intentions.
Idk, I’m probably just being too pedantic, but shit like that annoys me. “The human body was never intended to handle processed foods”. That shit does mean anything. What’s the consequence? Is there malnutrition? Problems with development of…..idk teeth or the GI system?
hamfisting_my_thing on
I lament this fact, especially given how much I love Trolli sour gummi worms.
liptickletaffy on
Do food deserts next Dr. David. God intends it!
Corran22 on
If I snort coke off a toilet seat will that make me healthier?
dingusmingus2222 on
But was it built to handle coke from a dirty toilet seat? Asking for a friend…
SkinnedIt on
Who cares, there’s money to be made and health care expenses to be paid!
Sea-Homework1991 on
And yet, here we are…
Bloaf on
> biology was never intended to handle“ ultraprocessed foods
of course not, that’s a teleological fallacy. Its the same reasoning anti-LGBTQ people use to argue that LGBTQ stuff is „unnatural“.
Ultraprocessed foods **were intended** to handle our biology, that’s the problem.
CardiologistOdd3203 on
This is a dude that can’t handle his Takis
Brilliant_Voice1126 on
Biology doesn’t have “intent”. While I admire Kessler’s intentions he’s not a scientist and never has been. This type of teleological thinking are why he has fallen into the trap of the naturalistic fallacy theoughout his career leading to the disastrous decision to help deregulation the supplements and vitamin trade spawning a million huxsters and an endless stream of health disinformation and antivax sentiments.
He needs to come with data, not the naturalistic fallacy. Nature doesn’t intend things. We’re all just a series of happy accidents.
givin_u_the_high_hat on
It’s crazy. The Dems voiced this concern a long time ago. It was the GOP that said kids should be allowed to choose ultra processed lunches and giant sodas, and a president that chooses McDonald’s over any other type of meal. They even showed up on Fox drinking from their Big Gulps.
Top_Pirate699 on
We were never intended to deal with a billionaire pedophile class intent on climate destruction, I’m a little more afraid of that than oreos
ro536ud on
What about Coke from a toilet seat tho?
pricklypear90 on
Dump that granulated sugar right in the trash
DiscombobulatedPain6 on
Well then why the fuck are you allowing people to make it? Lol
PlaxicoCN on
Things I have to work on for 100.
tardiscoder on
What exactly is ultra processed and when is it „ultra processed“ verses cooking?
OldGaffer66 on
So why didn’t he do something about it when he WAS FDA head? Too little too late, my little man.
deadbeatsummers on
I encourage everyone to read about the history of corporate lobbying against FDA regulations
superhappy on
Sure. But it’s what plants crave.
Paper_Clip100 on
But when Michelle Obama said we should limit ultra processed juices my cousins fucking FREAKED out in Facebook
banksy_h8r on
Same for raw dairy milk, but that’s not going to stop RFK Jr.
Avoidtolls on
Nor microplastics or Benzene,
nor_cal_woolgrower on
Were we even intended to handle cooked food?
lizkbyer on
And now I don’t believe a word that comes out of the departments mouth. That’s where we are. Congratulations.
guns_mahoney on
Funny that I’m seeing hamburger helper ads in the comments.
SaltyPinKY on
What about the animals that we force on processed food? I’m going to get hate for this…but I’ll trade a few years of longevity for everyone getting nutrition of some sort. I have no problem with processed foods.
biaggio on
I don’t trust anything from CBS News since the whole Bari Weiss thing.
thatsbutters on
There was never a plan intended… It’s been leroy jenkins from the start.
Effervescentgravy on
We have determined that human biology was never intended to ingest alcohol. So we are announcing a new policy called Prohibition.
Difficult_Ladder369 on
Like vegan food. It’s all processed. Chemicals and plants. If y’all only knew how many animals have to get killed for agricultural purposes
uncoolcentral on
Nor was it meant to handle driving, social media, or RFK.
Visible-Vermicelli-2 on
Isn’t this from the „Book Of Duh!“?
Sartres_Roommate on
Also weren’t designed to process milk after toddlerhood.
Competitive_Log_8981 on
Then why didn’t he do something about it when he was the head of the FDA?
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
48 Kommentare
Say more, try it in a way that makes sense.
It’s not like I want to advocate for processed foods, though you would be surprised how not-shelf-stable most things are. But this:
>David Kessler: Pick up any one of these products. You ever look at the– the ingredient label?
>Bill Whitaker: A lot of ‚em are things I can’t even pronounce.
>David Kessler: Right. Is that food? Corn syrup, corn solids, maltodextrin, dextrose, xylose, high-fructose corn syrup. And then these ingredients were subjected to industrial processing so that our system can’t handle it.
this is facebook grandma logic.
wasnt intended for my body to travel at 70mph either, yet in a car I do that every day.
So are you going to regulate it?
I mean, we could also break down corn, for example, into its various chemical components and make it sound frightening. The issue isn’t the stabilizing additives, it’s that we’ve trained our collective tastebuds and corporate food delivers for it.
But when Democrats talked about limiting the size of sodas, these same chuckleheads melted down. Now if they want to make good foods affordable instead of cheap calories, wonderful. But this ain’t that.
Survival of the unfittest
Yep. My body has been telling me that exact thing the past two weeks. Sucks. I love me some ultra processed food.
Water toxemia is a real thing and a 35 year old mother died in 2023 simply by drinking too much water on vacation, causing her brain to swell.
… but try living without it.
Wasn’t RFK Jr supposed to clean up the food supply?
we weren’t designed for extreme nacho flavor
we had to evolve for extreme nacho flavor
Well, biology, or rather biochemistry, can handle ultra processed food, but you will become sick over time from the high levels glucose and fructose they contain.
So we should improve school lunches? Make fresh food more available to poor people? Fill in food deserts?
This is not a scientific argument. Do better.
I blame the Great Depression and WW2
Spoken like a guy who doesn’t even have a high school level understanding of evolutionary biology.
“Never intended to handle”. That’s not even the right framing. Because clearly the human body CAN handle processed foods. It has been doing so for literal decades. And nothing in human evolution is “intended” for anything. It has functions, not intentions.
Idk, I’m probably just being too pedantic, but shit like that annoys me. “The human body was never intended to handle processed foods”. That shit does mean anything. What’s the consequence? Is there malnutrition? Problems with development of…..idk teeth or the GI system?
I lament this fact, especially given how much I love Trolli sour gummi worms.
Do food deserts next Dr. David. God intends it!
If I snort coke off a toilet seat will that make me healthier?
But was it built to handle coke from a dirty toilet seat? Asking for a friend…
Who cares, there’s money to be made and health care expenses to be paid!
And yet, here we are…
> biology was never intended to handle“ ultraprocessed foods
of course not, that’s a teleological fallacy. Its the same reasoning anti-LGBTQ people use to argue that LGBTQ stuff is „unnatural“.
Ultraprocessed foods **were intended** to handle our biology, that’s the problem.
This is a dude that can’t handle his Takis
Biology doesn’t have “intent”. While I admire Kessler’s intentions he’s not a scientist and never has been. This type of teleological thinking are why he has fallen into the trap of the naturalistic fallacy theoughout his career leading to the disastrous decision to help deregulation the supplements and vitamin trade spawning a million huxsters and an endless stream of health disinformation and antivax sentiments.
He needs to come with data, not the naturalistic fallacy. Nature doesn’t intend things. We’re all just a series of happy accidents.
It’s crazy. The Dems voiced this concern a long time ago. It was the GOP that said kids should be allowed to choose ultra processed lunches and giant sodas, and a president that chooses McDonald’s over any other type of meal. They even showed up on Fox drinking from their Big Gulps.
We were never intended to deal with a billionaire pedophile class intent on climate destruction, I’m a little more afraid of that than oreos
What about Coke from a toilet seat tho?
Dump that granulated sugar right in the trash
Well then why the fuck are you allowing people to make it? Lol
Things I have to work on for 100.
What exactly is ultra processed and when is it „ultra processed“ verses cooking?
So why didn’t he do something about it when he WAS FDA head? Too little too late, my little man.
I encourage everyone to read about the history of corporate lobbying against FDA regulations
Sure. But it’s what plants crave.
But when Michelle Obama said we should limit ultra processed juices my cousins fucking FREAKED out in Facebook
Same for raw dairy milk, but that’s not going to stop RFK Jr.
Nor microplastics or Benzene,
Were we even intended to handle cooked food?
And now I don’t believe a word that comes out of the departments mouth. That’s where we are. Congratulations.
Funny that I’m seeing hamburger helper ads in the comments.
What about the animals that we force on processed food? I’m going to get hate for this…but I’ll trade a few years of longevity for everyone getting nutrition of some sort. I have no problem with processed foods.
I don’t trust anything from CBS News since the whole Bari Weiss thing.
There was never a plan intended… It’s been leroy jenkins from the start.
We have determined that human biology was never intended to ingest alcohol. So we are announcing a new policy called Prohibition.
Like vegan food. It’s all processed. Chemicals and plants. If y’all only knew how many animals have to get killed for agricultural purposes
Nor was it meant to handle driving, social media, or RFK.
Isn’t this from the „Book Of Duh!“?
Also weren’t designed to process milk after toddlerhood.
Then why didn’t he do something about it when he was the head of the FDA?