CMAT, Lambrini Girls und The Blessed Madonna konterten auf Róisín Murphys jüngsten Trans-Post, in dem sie behauptete, sie habe „nichts zu verlieren“.
https://www.nme.com/news/music/cmat-lambrini-girls-and-the-blessed-madonna-hit-back-at-roisin-murphys-recent-trans-post-who-claims-she-has-nothing-to-lose-3902106
Von The_Ruck_Inspector
25 Kommentare
Jesus she’s doing a Glinner
Disappointing to see Roisin doubling down on this.
She’s about to learn that the venn diagram of those who like disco-ey electropop and are transphobes is two separate circles.
Of all the things going on in the world for people to be concerned about, strangers’ genitals should not be this high on anyone’s list
Witch hunting is as popular as it ever was.
I’ll never understand why people whose living depends on having a fan base can’t just keep their thoughts to themselves but instead have to go publishing them for all the world to see.
There’s any number of examples of people who ruined their careers or their lives and all they had to do is just shut up and smile and nod.
It’s weird.
Really sad to see this, you would hope with the career she has had and the space that the queer community has had for her, she would be more empathetic.
Roisin Murphy basically said something wrong, got pushback, half apologised and instead of MOVING ON LIKE A NORMAL PERSON, spent months stewing until she exploded with something completely stupid and offensive.
The defining characteristic of her, Glinner and co is a vindictive streak that ends up consuming them.
I just wanna look pretty and wear a dress. Why does like 25% of the population hate me for that 😭
Said this to someone the other day, and they disagreed, but I’m not surprised by this. She’s been an asshole on Twitter before and she comes across very unlikeable in any interview I’ve seen of her.
Anyone that punches down on a tiiiny community of people who are just minding their own business is a bad person. Murphy is a bad person.
I don’t understand why she would she would come out and make this statement publicly. How is this going to benefit her or her career?
What did she say that’s so anti trans? “Puberty blockers shouldn’t be given to vulnerable kids” Is that really crazy or anti trans? The culture war ravages on.
Disco Glinner.
I do wonder if these guys, who become obsessed with an issue that does not directly affect their own lives, could just unplug for the internet entirely for like 12 months, would they be redeemable?
Holy crap, I love Roisin Murphy, I had no idea.
Does she ever look at the crowds at her shows?? We’re all queer af
This would be fine if Roisin Murphy hadn’t played multiple pride events, she’s literally profited off her own hypocrisy
I would agree that such drugs need more research and shouldn’t be given to children.
I’m not going to comment too much on her hateful views because at this point I think it’s a given that she’s transphobic and horribly bigoted, and her ego deserves no further attention besides absolute refutation to her bigotry.
What I’m going to ask is this: career-wise, what on Earth is she thinking? She’s making experimental dance music… literally *the* music of the LGTBQIA+ community. We love that stuff. It’s actually crazy. Does she actually believe in TERF ideology that much that she’s willing to sink her entire career? Her career is BUILT on gay clubs and inclusive spaces.
I love that The Blessed Madonna’s take is to tell Murphy to go fuck herself and keep trans people out of her mouth.
Do people like this not see the irony in shutting down discussion, resorting to insult and censoring someone’s opinion?
I don’t like what you say so I will invalidate you by not allowing you to speak.
Seems so juvenile and pernicious.
Does this mean she won’t be haunting the lineup of every single irish festival in existence anymore?
For someone with nothing to lose, I bet she won’t stfu in a few months about losing everything.
She has follow up tweets where she explains her position a bit more and clearly says that she doesn’t hate trans people.
Most people’s takeaway from this will be that „Roisín Murphy hates trans people“ but I don’t think that’s necessarily true and the reality of the situation is more complicated than that.
And here it is again. Another person who has probably never been affected by a trans person mouthing off like they are some kind of expert. If anything she has probably benefited from trans people and made money off them.
Just a reminder folks, trans people make up a tiny section of the population. Most of us are unlikely to encounter a trans person. They didn’t rob your granny. They didn’t go into your kids school to indoctrinate children into their way of thinking or keep your kid off a sports team. They didn’t stop you getting a hospital bed or delay an ambulance getting to you.
Any feeling or opinion you probably have about trans people comes from the internet and mainly social media. You are not a doctor, you don’t know what medical and well thought out reason has been given to allow a child to have puberty blockers etc. which again, happens a lot less than you think.
Fair play to Roisin.
Regardless of whatever one thinks of Murphy’s views, I really question what kind of headspace she must have been in to say “yep, I’m gonna double down on this anti-trans stuff, never mind the potential affects on my entire career”. How could she be that naive? Unless she actually wants to become another Linehan/Rowling type
Some sage advice, RoRo, is to keep your trap shut when you are not 100% certain that you have the facts and that you understand them. It’s a lot harder to walk back from condemning something than it is to just stfu.