In Austria it’s choice, you can do *Zivildienst* instead.
YouKnow008 on
What’s the difference between ‚yes‘ and ‚de jure‘?
Connor49999 on
Choice and mandatory… sounds mutually exclusive. A lot of these terms could do with defining on the map. Not sure what infrequent means here.
Guilty-Literature312 on
I assume „De jure“ means that mandatory military service exists in the law, but no one actually has to serve at present.
This is precisely what is the case in the Netherlands. So the indication „no“ is wrong.
_sivizius on
It’s actually de jure in Germany as well. Mandatory military service wasn’t abolished, just suspended. It’s still in the constitution.
SaraJuno on
It’s not really a choice in Switzerland. You do military service or Zivildienst, and your Zivildienst is 1.5x the length of standard military service, unlike in Austria. Both Switzerland and Austria should be blue.
Stefan0_ on
Why is Singapore not colored in, we do have mandatory national service for all males. (Military, Police or Civil Defence)
Imaginary_Day_876 on
People who post shit like this should be banned.
AtlanticPortal on
Italy is wrong. It would’ve de jure. You’re automatically signed up by the municipality (which administers the list of residents for the interior ministry) and in case the draft is resumed (it’s suspended) then they already have the lists.
Sherpa-Dave on
What the heck happened to New Zealand?
MessageNo6008 on
Syria is no longer a yes, it’s voluntary
No-Deal8956 on
I’ll take a pass on “uncertain.”
CCriscal on
Badly researched. Germany has mandatory service, but actual drafting has been suspended for over a decade, which would qualify as „de jure“.
ItayMarlov on
W Switzerland
IK417 on
I think that in all the former Warsaw Pact that are now in NATO have the same „de jure“ service like in USA.
Imranus on
This maps should specifiy is it mandatory for everyone or only men. Because in most cases its second.
stabs_rittmeister on
What does „infrequent“ mean? is „De jure“ same as „mandatory service exists, but is suspended“? In that case Germany should be purple.
Rookie-Crookie on
If it’s by choice it can’t be mandatory or am I missing here something?
LuxLiner on
Why is New Zealand west of Australia? 😂
Exciting-Economist25 on
Is it de jure with Canada?
theng on
biased choice of colors
Rasmoosen on
Not exactly accurate for Thailand – you need to register and draw a card. Most men do not need to do military service.
Epeic on
Another stupid inaccurate map
neveronitever on
New Zealand’s been hit by some big surf lately. Moved it 4000km west.
mexican_shawarma on
Bahrain doesn’t have mandatory military service
RandomRavenboi on
What’s the difference between No and by Choice? Isn’t that how it works in all countries that don’t have mandatory service?
dexbydesign89 on
It’s technically mandatory in Australia as well under section 59 of the Defence Act 1903. Albeit in very specific conditions, but section 59 specifically creates a power to call up people:
> 59 Persons liable to serve in Defence Force in time of war
>All persons (except those who are exempt from service under this Part or to whom this Part does not apply) who: (a) have resided in Australia for not less than 6 months; and (c) have attained the age of 18 years but have not attained the age of 60 years; are liable, when called upon under section 60, to serve in the Defence Force.
The order to conscript persons into the military has to be issued by the Governor-General, and there must be a declared war. The order doesn’t take effect until it is approved by both Houses of Parliament within 90 days. But it remains a theoretical possibility.
MiguelIstNeugierig on
In Portugal, all men and women must sign up to the reserves when they reach 18 at a special presentation of the armed forces that happens in select military bases depending on where you live
DrSkullKid on
I’m pretty certain military service isn’t mandatory in Brazil.
Dragonogard549 on
What’s the difference between choice and no
Dragonogard549 on
What’s the difference between choice and no
XxTensai on
– Mandatory
– Choice
RN_Renato on
In Brazil if you are from rural areas or small towns you are pretty much automatically exempted
GamerBoixX on
Whats the difference between „choice“ and „no“?
Elyza666 on
Sweden is basically a mandatory questionnaire and then the military evaluates if you are fit enough for service.
niemertweis on
if choice means to pay 3% of your salary every year instead
Ousis24 on
Latvia is mandatory for every male who lose national lottery
JaMi_1980 on
What’s the difference between „de jure“ and „yes“?
„Yes“ would mean that there is mandatory military service without legal basis.
Jeepnovice on
What the hell happened to New Zealand?
AbideTheCold on
Incorrect for India. The Indian constitution (Article 23) provides the State with the power to impose compulsory service for public purposes which is interpreted to include Military service as well. It has never been used though, so India should be “de jure” as well.
vassaloatena on
In Brazil, military service is „de jure“ too.
Luca_Small_Flowers on
This is incorrect: Italy should be coloured as „de jure“ too.
AngelReachX on
While here in México it is technically mandatory, barely anyone does it. It used to be needed to be elegible for most jobs but its just not anymore
OldAge6093 on
What does choice mean under mandatory service
tehdusto on
r/mapswithnewzealandbut
StrongAdhesiveness86 on
Spain is wrong
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
47 Kommentare
What does it mean mandatory by choise?
In Austria it’s choice, you can do *Zivildienst* instead.
What’s the difference between ‚yes‘ and ‚de jure‘?
Choice and mandatory… sounds mutually exclusive. A lot of these terms could do with defining on the map. Not sure what infrequent means here.
I assume „De jure“ means that mandatory military service exists in the law, but no one actually has to serve at present.
This is precisely what is the case in the Netherlands. So the indication „no“ is wrong.
It’s actually de jure in Germany as well. Mandatory military service wasn’t abolished, just suspended. It’s still in the constitution.
It’s not really a choice in Switzerland. You do military service or Zivildienst, and your Zivildienst is 1.5x the length of standard military service, unlike in Austria. Both Switzerland and Austria should be blue.
Why is Singapore not colored in, we do have mandatory national service for all males. (Military, Police or Civil Defence)
People who post shit like this should be banned.
Italy is wrong. It would’ve de jure. You’re automatically signed up by the municipality (which administers the list of residents for the interior ministry) and in case the draft is resumed (it’s suspended) then they already have the lists.
What the heck happened to New Zealand?
Syria is no longer a yes, it’s voluntary
I’ll take a pass on “uncertain.”
Badly researched. Germany has mandatory service, but actual drafting has been suspended for over a decade, which would qualify as „de jure“.
W Switzerland
I think that in all the former Warsaw Pact that are now in NATO have the same „de jure“ service like in USA.
This maps should specifiy is it mandatory for everyone or only men. Because in most cases its second.
What does „infrequent“ mean? is „De jure“ same as „mandatory service exists, but is suspended“? In that case Germany should be purple.
If it’s by choice it can’t be mandatory or am I missing here something?
Why is New Zealand west of Australia? 😂
Is it de jure with Canada?
biased choice of colors
Not exactly accurate for Thailand – you need to register and draw a card. Most men do not need to do military service.
Another stupid inaccurate map
New Zealand’s been hit by some big surf lately. Moved it 4000km west.
Bahrain doesn’t have mandatory military service
What’s the difference between No and by Choice? Isn’t that how it works in all countries that don’t have mandatory service?
It’s technically mandatory in Australia as well under section 59 of the Defence Act 1903. Albeit in very specific conditions, but section 59 specifically creates a power to call up people:
> 59 Persons liable to serve in Defence Force in time of war
>All persons (except those who are exempt from service under this Part or to whom this Part does not apply) who: (a) have resided in Australia for not less than 6 months; and (c) have attained the age of 18 years but have not attained the age of 60 years; are liable, when called upon under section 60, to serve in the Defence Force.
The order to conscript persons into the military has to be issued by the Governor-General, and there must be a declared war. The order doesn’t take effect until it is approved by both Houses of Parliament within 90 days. But it remains a theoretical possibility.
In Portugal, all men and women must sign up to the reserves when they reach 18 at a special presentation of the armed forces that happens in select military bases depending on where you live
I’m pretty certain military service isn’t mandatory in Brazil.
What’s the difference between choice and no
What’s the difference between choice and no
– Mandatory
– Choice
In Brazil if you are from rural areas or small towns you are pretty much automatically exempted
Whats the difference between „choice“ and „no“?
Sweden is basically a mandatory questionnaire and then the military evaluates if you are fit enough for service.
if choice means to pay 3% of your salary every year instead
Latvia is mandatory for every male who lose national lottery
What’s the difference between „de jure“ and „yes“?
„Yes“ would mean that there is mandatory military service without legal basis.
What the hell happened to New Zealand?
Incorrect for India. The Indian constitution (Article 23) provides the State with the power to impose compulsory service for public purposes which is interpreted to include Military service as well. It has never been used though, so India should be “de jure” as well.
In Brazil, military service is „de jure“ too.
This is incorrect: Italy should be coloured as „de jure“ too.
While here in México it is technically mandatory, barely anyone does it. It used to be needed to be elegible for most jobs but its just not anymore
What does choice mean under mandatory service
r/mapswithnewzealandbut
Spain is wrong