Lindsey Halligan, the White House official leading a review of the Smithsonian Institution, argued you „can’t really talk about slavery honestly unless you talk about hope and progress“ during a Newsmax appearance on Wednesday.
Halligan, a special assistant to the president, said she had written to the Smithsonian „asking for more information regarding their exhibits“ after claiming the group’s museums had become „laboratories for political experiments.“
Nothing says hope and progress like *checks the quote again* slavery?
This is not a thought that should have been shared. Ever.
drtolmn69 on
„_In fact, we’ve been working to bring it back for decades in the guise of mass incarceration, and so far, it’s looking good!_“
Dingus_Suckimus on
Der Reichstag says holocaust is being taught wrong, should not be so negative. Should focus more on positivity, how a substantial number of jews were liquidated.
Goebbels, the special assistant to Der Führer, says „Museums have become too political. The exhibitions are based on real history, which is terribly inconvenient for our agenda.“
lundah on
Well this is what happens when you outsource the Department of Education to PragerU.
ranchoparksteve on
I guess conservatives don’t hear how stupid they sound on this issue. Describing slavery as some sort of skills training and self improvement retreat is absolutely ridiculous. The denial runs deep.
thieh on
Every person who said current teachings of slavery being too negative should be turned into slaves for a few generations. It wouldn’t be so bad if they don’t think it’s that bad, right?
JimFknLahey on
At what point can The Onion(tm) sue ?
fowlraul on
“Was slavery as cool as it sounds, or was there a downside? 🤔
AmrokMC on
“Slavery is better than death, right?” – PragerU (which is now being pushed to replace PBS).
“Give me liberty, or give me death” – Patrick Henry, one of the Founding Fathers of the United States
Rare-Ad-9088 on
Theres three things we need to be looked at harshly for always. Other things we can definitely debate
1. US treatment of black people slavery/segregation
2. US treatment of Native Americans/Indigenous people
3. US treatment of Japanese Americans during WW2
ThunderChild247 on
We all said this back when Trump named his campaign “Make America Great Again”, we asked him to say when he thought it was great. Jim Crow? When women couldn’t vote? Back when you could own people? And I remember a lot of push back saying that was a bit extreme.
Well, here we are. Time to talk up the fun parts of slavery. I wonder how long it’ll be before we get a 4K re-release of Song of the South at the order of the White House.
pontiacfirebird92 on
They sold black slaves in the same way they sold farm equipment at auctions. They treated human beings like they would a tractor (probably worse considering). And they were willing to secede from the United States to continue to do so.
Republicans are trying to say this was normal and fine?
cassettes_01 on
Imagine thinking you can speak like this and then go out into the country, unaffected. This spokeswoman thinks she can say these things, go out to a restaurant, buys groceries, etc… without any pushback.
User4C4C4C on
“Whenever [I] hear any one, arguing for slavery I feel a strong impulse to see it tried on him personally.” —Abraham Lincoln
ceored on
That scene in 12 years a slave where they break the guys teeth to force feed him… really says it all about the violence needed to keep chattel slavery running.
Who can defend that in a good faith way? It’s not possible.
Also scares the hell out of me because that sh*t was happening with our constitution in place. That’s why a lot of Americans like myself want to be realistic about who we were, who we are and who we want to be.
Sleeping_Echoes on
They have to justify it someway since they want to bring it back so they can justify the tariff and other crazy bullshit for that day.
Accurate-Guava-3337 on
This is really slipping under the radar. Diminishing the history and teaching of slavery should be a nonstarter at the very least.
shawn_overlord on
What is that even supposed to mean?? Like how are we supposed to reconcile our government is literally telling us to sanitize history? There’s no other way to interpret this kind of sentiment
Bigotry and ignorance infested this country long ago and the sickness is apparent in the symptoms; slavery was ‚good‘, being LGBT is ‚wrong‘, empathy is a ’sin‘, racism doesn’t ‚exist‘, all minorities are ‚criminals‘
The president is a literal demented boomer implementing Facebook-level old-people slop as policy
citizenjones on
I think Trump and the GOP should speak more about ‚how‘ & ‚why‘ that slavery „wasn’t that bad'“.
… And it goes a little something like this…
*Her family own slaves…. Says grandchildren of slaves aren’t as happy….*
>I think we need to be focusing on the progress that we’ve made then and we need to stop focusing so much on the lack of progress.
„Noooooo don’t talk about the lack of progress talk about the progress not the lack of it you guys stop talking about the lack of progress, we don’t actually torture you as much anymore, don’t look at the systemic racism we still do just look at how we used to be so much worse but don’t talk about that either, stop being so negative!“
Hollywood_1984 on
Stop with the nonsense …
EscapedTheEcho on
I’ve said it before: in addition to wanting to repeal the 4th, 14th,19th, & 22nd, amendments, republicans are coming for the 13th next.
DeltaFoxtrot144 on
why so they can try and bring it back in a couple years? Hard fucking pass. is he seriously out here doing a PR Image rehabilitation for fucking slavery? if he was a dog Kristy knobslooberNoem would have put him down by now
Scarfwearer on
Fuck You all the way around WH.
Trump is racist, pedo, wannabe dictator who you all are worshipping as a god king in your cult.
He will go down in history as one of the worst presidents this hellhole ever conjured up.
Constantinople2020 on
>Lindsey Halligan, the White House official leading a review of the Smithsonian Institution, said
>Referring to slavery…“It’s not about whitewashing it’s about full context, so while slavery is obviously a horrible aspect of our nation’s history you can’t really talk about slavery honestly unless you also talk about hope and progress and I think we need to be focusing on the progress that we’ve made then and we need to stop focusing so much on the lack of progress.“
Much of the initial hope and progress came through fighting against Confederate generals in the Civil War, the same generals whom Trump wants to memorialize through statuary.
SquashDue502 on
Yeah you can teach progress by showing progress. Show how black Americans now have equal opportunity and how reparations were made to them. Oh wait, we got rid of DEI and don’t believe reparations are possible. 💀
Civil-Addendum4071 on
Absolutely disgusting rhetoric. Attempting to trick one into thinking a cancer is healthy for their body will not stop said cancer from killing them.
Release the Goddamn Epstein files.
fermat9990 on
How about the Tulsa Massacre and the Trail of Tears? Are we missing the fun parts?
sniffstink1 on
The „White“ House has spoken.
I wonder if these complete morons are feeling stupid right about now:
Yeah, it was good for the economy, kept unemployment low, school enrollment low, no one on welfare, no problems with desegregation, no EEO hires, the courts not clogged with claims of discrimination. It was a golden era for some.
Queasy-Protection-50 on
This is bullshit and it’s wrong. Anyone who supports this is someone looking to openly be a racist.
blakester555 on
Isn’t this the exact term for _**WHITE WASHING**_?
skeptolojist on
Sounds like the sort of thing someone who wants to own slaves would say
calliope3234 on
I just feel bad for satirists at this point the fact that that is a real headline
attillathehoney on
Meanwhile, Florida’s new African American history standards for public schools were defended by Governor Ron DeSantis. These standards, adopted in 2023, include a line stating that middle schoolers should be taught that “slaves developed skills which, in some instances, could be applied for their personal benefit”. So you see, slavery was actually good for black people.
Is_Only_Game2014 on
What an odd thing to say
TyphosTheD on
Giving the overwhelming benefit of the doubt, at best they’re saying that the Smithsonian and curriculum covering Slavery should also cover the context around when Slavery was [partially] ended and how American culture [partially] advanced in ways that improved the lives and opportunities of POC to pursue Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.
That’s an admirable goal, I think most could agree.
But… I’ve been to the Smithsonian, and I’ve been through public schooling. The Smithsonian **did** cover those topics, and I **did** learn about those things in school.
It just so happens that the evil of owning people, the fact that a civil war was fought over it, that politicians actively sought and still do to maintain the institution of slavery to this day, and that at no point was any step of „progress“ not tainted with some „gotcha“ that meant POC still were treated like second class citizens, overshadowed much of that.
Vapur9 on
Cool. Then we can belt our President and Congressmen to show them how great it is to be a servant to the People.
HopInHeimer on
This mf administration…put them in fucking chains and ask them then..
What a fucking disaster this is …slavery isn’t THAT bad….
Americans you need to wake up….
ThirdSunRising on
When we’re done talking up the benefits of slavery, maybe we could begin a conversation about how wonderful the holocaust was
marktruslow on
Only this fucking idiot occupying the WH would say something as fucking stupid as this!
kuppikuppi on
might be because the working conditions in America are coming closer and closer to slavery so you have to give it a positive spin.
And obviously they are racist as fuck.
Zanos-Ixshlae on
Sure, let’s take our lead from a racist child raping bigot.
mgfan2029 on
You can’t make this shit up.
KnightDuty on
„My feelings keep getting hurt and that’s your fault“ – Every republican.
Jindabyne1 on
Looks like confederates won the Cold War
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
47 Kommentare
By James Bickerton – US News Reporter:
Lindsey Halligan, the White House official leading a review of the Smithsonian Institution, argued you „can’t really talk about slavery honestly unless you talk about hope and progress“ during a Newsmax appearance on Wednesday.
Halligan, a special assistant to the president, said she had written to the Smithsonian „asking for more information regarding their exhibits“ after claiming the group’s museums had become „laboratories for political experiments.“
Read more: [https://www.newsweek.com/white-house-says-slavery-being-taught-wrong-should-not-so-negative-2117100?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=reddit_main](https://www.newsweek.com/white-house-says-slavery-being-taught-wrong-should-not-so-negative-2117100?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=reddit_main)
Nothing says hope and progress like *checks the quote again* slavery?
This is not a thought that should have been shared. Ever.
„_In fact, we’ve been working to bring it back for decades in the guise of mass incarceration, and so far, it’s looking good!_“
Der Reichstag says holocaust is being taught wrong, should not be so negative. Should focus more on positivity, how a substantial number of jews were liquidated.
Goebbels, the special assistant to Der Führer, says „Museums have become too political. The exhibitions are based on real history, which is terribly inconvenient for our agenda.“
Well this is what happens when you outsource the Department of Education to PragerU.
I guess conservatives don’t hear how stupid they sound on this issue. Describing slavery as some sort of skills training and self improvement retreat is absolutely ridiculous. The denial runs deep.
Every person who said current teachings of slavery being too negative should be turned into slaves for a few generations. It wouldn’t be so bad if they don’t think it’s that bad, right?
At what point can The Onion(tm) sue ?
“Was slavery as cool as it sounds, or was there a downside? 🤔
“Slavery is better than death, right?” – PragerU (which is now being pushed to replace PBS).
“Give me liberty, or give me death” – Patrick Henry, one of the Founding Fathers of the United States
Theres three things we need to be looked at harshly for always. Other things we can definitely debate
1. US treatment of black people slavery/segregation
2. US treatment of Native Americans/Indigenous people
3. US treatment of Japanese Americans during WW2
We all said this back when Trump named his campaign “Make America Great Again”, we asked him to say when he thought it was great. Jim Crow? When women couldn’t vote? Back when you could own people? And I remember a lot of push back saying that was a bit extreme.
Well, here we are. Time to talk up the fun parts of slavery. I wonder how long it’ll be before we get a 4K re-release of Song of the South at the order of the White House.
They sold black slaves in the same way they sold farm equipment at auctions. They treated human beings like they would a tractor (probably worse considering). And they were willing to secede from the United States to continue to do so.
Republicans are trying to say this was normal and fine?
Imagine thinking you can speak like this and then go out into the country, unaffected. This spokeswoman thinks she can say these things, go out to a restaurant, buys groceries, etc… without any pushback.
“Whenever [I] hear any one, arguing for slavery I feel a strong impulse to see it tried on him personally.” —Abraham Lincoln
That scene in 12 years a slave where they break the guys teeth to force feed him… really says it all about the violence needed to keep chattel slavery running.
Who can defend that in a good faith way? It’s not possible.
Also scares the hell out of me because that sh*t was happening with our constitution in place. That’s why a lot of Americans like myself want to be realistic about who we were, who we are and who we want to be.
They have to justify it someway since they want to bring it back so they can justify the tariff and other crazy bullshit for that day.
This is really slipping under the radar. Diminishing the history and teaching of slavery should be a nonstarter at the very least.
What is that even supposed to mean?? Like how are we supposed to reconcile our government is literally telling us to sanitize history? There’s no other way to interpret this kind of sentiment
Bigotry and ignorance infested this country long ago and the sickness is apparent in the symptoms; slavery was ‚good‘, being LGBT is ‚wrong‘, empathy is a ’sin‘, racism doesn’t ‚exist‘, all minorities are ‚criminals‘
The president is a literal demented boomer implementing Facebook-level old-people slop as policy
I think Trump and the GOP should speak more about ‚how‘ & ‚why‘ that slavery „wasn’t that bad'“.
… And it goes a little something like this…
*Her family own slaves…. Says grandchildren of slaves aren’t as happy….*
https://youtu.be/FuyWEpeNfew?si=kBJF1eAYbtmvDYxH
>I think we need to be focusing on the progress that we’ve made then and we need to stop focusing so much on the lack of progress.
„Noooooo don’t talk about the lack of progress talk about the progress not the lack of it you guys stop talking about the lack of progress, we don’t actually torture you as much anymore, don’t look at the systemic racism we still do just look at how we used to be so much worse but don’t talk about that either, stop being so negative!“
Stop with the nonsense …
I’ve said it before: in addition to wanting to repeal the 4th, 14th,19th, & 22nd, amendments, republicans are coming for the 13th next.
why so they can try and bring it back in a couple years? Hard fucking pass. is he seriously out here doing a PR Image rehabilitation for fucking slavery? if he was a dog Kristy knobslooberNoem would have put him down by now
Fuck You all the way around WH.
Trump is racist, pedo, wannabe dictator who you all are worshipping as a god king in your cult.
He will go down in history as one of the worst presidents this hellhole ever conjured up.
>Lindsey Halligan, the White House official leading a review of the Smithsonian Institution, said
>Referring to slavery…“It’s not about whitewashing it’s about full context, so while slavery is obviously a horrible aspect of our nation’s history you can’t really talk about slavery honestly unless you also talk about hope and progress and I think we need to be focusing on the progress that we’ve made then and we need to stop focusing so much on the lack of progress.“
Much of the initial hope and progress came through fighting against Confederate generals in the Civil War, the same generals whom Trump wants to memorialize through statuary.
Yeah you can teach progress by showing progress. Show how black Americans now have equal opportunity and how reparations were made to them. Oh wait, we got rid of DEI and don’t believe reparations are possible. 💀
Absolutely disgusting rhetoric. Attempting to trick one into thinking a cancer is healthy for their body will not stop said cancer from killing them.
Release the Goddamn Epstein files.
How about the Tulsa Massacre and the Trail of Tears? Are we missing the fun parts?
The „White“ House has spoken.
I wonder if these complete morons are feeling stupid right about now:
https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/trump-administration/focus-group-black-men-backed-trump-approve-presidency-raise-concerns-d-rcna197046
Yeah, it was good for the economy, kept unemployment low, school enrollment low, no one on welfare, no problems with desegregation, no EEO hires, the courts not clogged with claims of discrimination. It was a golden era for some.
This is bullshit and it’s wrong. Anyone who supports this is someone looking to openly be a racist.
Isn’t this the exact term for _**WHITE WASHING**_?
Sounds like the sort of thing someone who wants to own slaves would say
I just feel bad for satirists at this point the fact that that is a real headline
Meanwhile, Florida’s new African American history standards for public schools were defended by Governor Ron DeSantis. These standards, adopted in 2023, include a line stating that middle schoolers should be taught that “slaves developed skills which, in some instances, could be applied for their personal benefit”. So you see, slavery was actually good for black people.
What an odd thing to say
Giving the overwhelming benefit of the doubt, at best they’re saying that the Smithsonian and curriculum covering Slavery should also cover the context around when Slavery was [partially] ended and how American culture [partially] advanced in ways that improved the lives and opportunities of POC to pursue Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness.
That’s an admirable goal, I think most could agree.
But… I’ve been to the Smithsonian, and I’ve been through public schooling. The Smithsonian **did** cover those topics, and I **did** learn about those things in school.
It just so happens that the evil of owning people, the fact that a civil war was fought over it, that politicians actively sought and still do to maintain the institution of slavery to this day, and that at no point was any step of „progress“ not tainted with some „gotcha“ that meant POC still were treated like second class citizens, overshadowed much of that.
Cool. Then we can belt our President and Congressmen to show them how great it is to be a servant to the People.
This mf administration…put them in fucking chains and ask them then..
What a fucking disaster this is …slavery isn’t THAT bad….
Americans you need to wake up….
When we’re done talking up the benefits of slavery, maybe we could begin a conversation about how wonderful the holocaust was
Only this fucking idiot occupying the WH would say something as fucking stupid as this!
might be because the working conditions in America are coming closer and closer to slavery so you have to give it a positive spin.
And obviously they are racist as fuck.
Sure, let’s take our lead from a racist child raping bigot.
You can’t make this shit up.
„My feelings keep getting hurt and that’s your fault“ – Every republican.
Looks like confederates won the Cold War