Justice loses its meaning if it’s only for the powerless
General_Meade on
Okay? Cool? Thank you, mayor of a city who has absolutely no impact on foreign policy.
This man promised he would arrest him during the campaign and then pretends like he just now „reviewed‘ the issue and decided he cannot do it. He knew all along he had no power here.
Jacobin remains glazing this man, even when he makes a whole video admitting his promise was a failure.
noyoto on
The ICC is right. Mamdani is simply not rebelling against international law.
Blue-22 on
This whole thing is prolonged this much because Bibi’s own government wants to jail him for corruption and as long as there’s a war going on, they can’t do that. He’s just adding to his list of crimes at this point and showing how little he values anyone but himself.
You could also substitute „Trump“ in for Bibi and the same paragraph still somewhat applies.
super-gando on
And some more …. and starts with Trump and his syphon
zenbowman on
That’s true, but its also true of Xi, Putin, Trump, etc. Not sure why calling for the arrest of foreign tyrants should be a litmus test, because in the long run it is a test that will overwhelmingly benefit neoconservatives.
bad_timing_bro on
Is this just going to be the DSA’s “Lock Her Up” and nothing actually comes of it?
gatorfan93 on
Too bad nothing can be done about it. The U.S. is not a member of the International Criminal Court (ICC) and does not recognize its warrants. Furthermore, a 2002 U.S. law explicitly prohibits extraditing anyone to the ICC, and to top it all off, sitting heads of state hold diplomatic immunity under domestic and United Nations protocols.
Cheshire_Khajiit on
Agreed, even if I think Jacobin being right says more about the grievous crimes Bibi has committed than the trustworthiness of Jacobin as a source of information.
nasorrty346tfrgser on
He certainly is, but i mean he is only a NYC mayor. He is a great man, but his power has limit.
That’s something that our president should be doing
bluehoag on
Wow, courageous take r/politics.
0kafaraqgatri0 on
And hopefully the Israeli courts will finally finish his trial. There have been PMs that have gone to prison in the past, hopefully he will be there soon. (And then Ben Gvir and Smotrich will follow.)
JDDJS on
Does Netanyahu belong in jail? Yes. Does a mayor have any power to arrest him himself? No, of course not. I like Mamdani a lot, but even entertaining the idea of arranging for Netanyahu to be arrested was completely ridiculous. Mayors very obviously cannot arrest foreign world leaders on for crimes that happened in other countries. It’s fine that he’s openly calling for the federal government to arrest him even though they extremely obviously won’t. But don’t entertain ridiculous ideas that would clearly be overstepping his authority.
froyolobro on
I mean, trump too, but here we are
Coach_Hab on
The sooner the better …
But that would pave the way for another of those Likoud cowards to push the them against us bullshit narrative
Knighth77 on
Implicating Netanyahu implicates his partner in crime, the US. Never going to happen. There’s a reason why the US have been fighting against any sort of repercussions or accountability against Israel for all these years. They’re partners.
Simpleximo on
put him in cell next to Trump
ikindahateusernames on
>Netanyahu Belongs Behind Bars.
Okay then. Why stop there? That’s the only head of state Mamdani has singled out in such a fashion, yet Netanyahu is far from the only one who should be tried.
Seriously, he’s not beating the anti-semitism allegations with stunts like this. If someone only cares about human rights violations when they’re alleged against the world’s only Jewish-majority state, and no one else, they should just embrace their bigotry at this point.
Odd-Strength-3789 on
Mamdani just said he won’t have Netanyahu if he comes to NY.
Hairy_Technology_213 on
Guy should probably focus on making sure the trash gets picked up on time.
Nervous-Season8159 on
wait how did mamdani say that exactly
Medium_Double4522 on
Duh
The_Pandalorian on
He’s also right — and humble enough to acknowledge — that he isn’t the one to do it.
OkSupport5990 on
What is he doing about it?
muskoka83 on
Who cares if he is right? MANY have said this for years before him. This isn’t on his shoulders. Ugh.
doesntgetthepicture on
So do a lot of world leaders that come to the UN. If we started arresting all of them no one would come to the UN and it would defeat the purpose of the UN.
I would love to see Netanyahu arrested. But arresting him for visiting NYC for diplomatic purposes is hugely problematic.
And I find it equally problematic that we haven’t said the same about any other world leader who has committed war crimes and come to the UN for diplomatic reasons. Putin for example, or Ahmadinejad, among others.
SamuraiCook on
Yeah but Mamdani needs to focus on NYC before they catch him slipping.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
28 Kommentare
I agree 100%.
Justice loses its meaning if it’s only for the powerless
Okay? Cool? Thank you, mayor of a city who has absolutely no impact on foreign policy.
This man promised he would arrest him during the campaign and then pretends like he just now „reviewed‘ the issue and decided he cannot do it. He knew all along he had no power here.
Jacobin remains glazing this man, even when he makes a whole video admitting his promise was a failure.
The ICC is right. Mamdani is simply not rebelling against international law.
This whole thing is prolonged this much because Bibi’s own government wants to jail him for corruption and as long as there’s a war going on, they can’t do that. He’s just adding to his list of crimes at this point and showing how little he values anyone but himself.
You could also substitute „Trump“ in for Bibi and the same paragraph still somewhat applies.
And some more …. and starts with Trump and his syphon
That’s true, but its also true of Xi, Putin, Trump, etc. Not sure why calling for the arrest of foreign tyrants should be a litmus test, because in the long run it is a test that will overwhelmingly benefit neoconservatives.
Is this just going to be the DSA’s “Lock Her Up” and nothing actually comes of it?
Too bad nothing can be done about it. The U.S. is not a member of the International Criminal Court (ICC) and does not recognize its warrants. Furthermore, a 2002 U.S. law explicitly prohibits extraditing anyone to the ICC, and to top it all off, sitting heads of state hold diplomatic immunity under domestic and United Nations protocols.
Agreed, even if I think Jacobin being right says more about the grievous crimes Bibi has committed than the trustworthiness of Jacobin as a source of information.
He certainly is, but i mean he is only a NYC mayor. He is a great man, but his power has limit.
That’s something that our president should be doing
Wow, courageous take r/politics.
And hopefully the Israeli courts will finally finish his trial. There have been PMs that have gone to prison in the past, hopefully he will be there soon. (And then Ben Gvir and Smotrich will follow.)
Does Netanyahu belong in jail? Yes. Does a mayor have any power to arrest him himself? No, of course not. I like Mamdani a lot, but even entertaining the idea of arranging for Netanyahu to be arrested was completely ridiculous. Mayors very obviously cannot arrest foreign world leaders on for crimes that happened in other countries. It’s fine that he’s openly calling for the federal government to arrest him even though they extremely obviously won’t. But don’t entertain ridiculous ideas that would clearly be overstepping his authority.
I mean, trump too, but here we are
The sooner the better …
But that would pave the way for another of those Likoud cowards to push the them against us bullshit narrative
Implicating Netanyahu implicates his partner in crime, the US. Never going to happen. There’s a reason why the US have been fighting against any sort of repercussions or accountability against Israel for all these years. They’re partners.
put him in cell next to Trump
>Netanyahu Belongs Behind Bars.
Okay then. Why stop there? That’s the only head of state Mamdani has singled out in such a fashion, yet Netanyahu is far from the only one who should be tried.
Seriously, he’s not beating the anti-semitism allegations with stunts like this. If someone only cares about human rights violations when they’re alleged against the world’s only Jewish-majority state, and no one else, they should just embrace their bigotry at this point.
Mamdani just said he won’t have Netanyahu if he comes to NY.
Guy should probably focus on making sure the trash gets picked up on time.
wait how did mamdani say that exactly
Duh
He’s also right — and humble enough to acknowledge — that he isn’t the one to do it.
What is he doing about it?
Who cares if he is right? MANY have said this for years before him. This isn’t on his shoulders. Ugh.
So do a lot of world leaders that come to the UN. If we started arresting all of them no one would come to the UN and it would defeat the purpose of the UN.
I would love to see Netanyahu arrested. But arresting him for visiting NYC for diplomatic purposes is hugely problematic.
And I find it equally problematic that we haven’t said the same about any other world leader who has committed war crimes and come to the UN for diplomatic reasons. Putin for example, or Ahmadinejad, among others.
Yeah but Mamdani needs to focus on NYC before they catch him slipping.