Die Ukraine fordert, Russland seinen Status als ständiges Mitglied des UN-Sicherheitsrates zu entziehen
https://nashaniva.com/en/395707
Die Ukraine fordert, Russland seinen Status als ständiges Mitglied des UN-Sicherheitsrates zu entziehen
https://nashaniva.com/en/395707
23 Kommentare
To which a majority of member states vote yes, and then Russia vetos the vote.
More like the UN Insecurity Council!!
🥁🥁
>The Security Council shall consist of fifteen Members of the United Nations. The Republic of China, France, **the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics**, the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, and the United States of America shall be permanent members of the Security Council.
The UN Charter doesnt mention Russia, so that seat formerly held by the USSR should be left vacant.
That wouldn’t work. The entire UN Permament Security Council Seat was created in Post-WW2 solely to mantain the sphere of influences of the great winners at that decade, with far more power than the other members of UN.
All will do is for the other seats says ‚yes“ and Russia says „no“ and that be the end of it, because Permament Seats have full veto powers.
That’s not the only country that shouldn’t have a seat.
I concur
it’s not even possible
the way the UN is setup makes it easy to add a country to the UN and basically impossible to remove one from the council, you may as well dissolve the UN and create a new organisation from scratch
Wishful thinking
This is cute. I am really keen to see how many countries will say yes
I‘d consider it more likely that Trump will propose Putin as honorary chairman for the Security Council
First, it will not be possible because it will be vetoed. Secondly, Russia has the power to ignore any UN security resolution, similar to other Security Council permanent members. Giving them the seat/veto makes diplomacy easier to conduct.
The seat is not where the power is, its the other way round where the hard power gave them the right to the seat.
Russia lost any claim to dictate Ukraine’s future the moment it tried to conquer it by force.
Ukraine doesn’t need Moscow’s permission to choose its alliances, its security or its future that’s what sovereignty actually means.
It needs to be done
As if the UN Security Council is something real.
Mandatory.
Should have been done many, many years ago
How about making the vote on that Russia should keep its seat. Then some other country could veto…
United Negligence
Maybe the UN could create an insecurity council for Putin and Trump?
Where do I sign
I will forever believe the UN is basically Useless on matters of war.
Okay let’s imagine for a moment Russia is kicked off.
Then the rest of the security Council wants to do something and Russia really doesn’t like that.
Russia says, don’t do that or I will nuke you.
If the other countries back off then the end result is Russia having a veto exactly as they currently do.
China is also a permanent member of the security Council and would likely veto things that go against Russia anyways.
It is unfortunate that the UN security Council doesn’t seem to do much of anything these days but not doing something that would greatly anger a nuclear armed country is arguably it’s real purpose and maybe doing next to nothing has helped avoid nuclear war.
Russia bypassing the UN and launching an aggressive expansionist war of choice against Ukraine is the real problem. If everyone just does what they want and doesn’t even try to justify their war to the United Nations the body becomes less relevant and less able to function.
I will say I disagree with Trump dropping sanctions on Russian oil. As long as Russia is at war with Ukraine they should be under heavy economic pressure from as much of the world as possible to stop.
Why would they do that? Isn’t the point of the UN to facilitate communication between all countries on earth?
We should remove all of them 5 and replace them with:
Italy
Luxembourg
Germany
South Africa
Brazil