Europe doing federal vs unitary like it’s a fashion trend lol
Alcol1979 on
Italy is formally unitary but highly decentralised to its regions.
KindRange9697 on
Just because Russia calls itself a federal state, doesn’t mean its true
nim_opet on
Stop with this ridiculous “it’s complicated” label.
Truelz on
If the UK is in the „It’s comlicated“ category then I would argue that Denmark should be so as well, as it’s a pretty similar situation with Greenland and the Faroes Islands being autonomous territories of the Kingdom of Denmark
azhder on
Too simplistic.
Spain is deliberately ambiguous in its constitution. Switzerland I think might be a confederacy, don’t know the details. Bosnia-Herzegovina is none of the above due to still having a UN representative holding certain powers i.e. not even fully sovereign state in its own right…
RoiDrannoc on
Metropolitan France is a unitary state. But New Caledonia and French Polynesia are integral parts of France and suddenly France is a Federal state with 3 quite autonomous subdivisions…
Bilaakili on
Had to think for a while what makes Finland so complicated. I guess it’s Åland.
vaivai22 on
On a technical level, there are four categories Unitary (most states), Devolved (UK), Federal (Germany, the US, Australia etc) and Confederation (Currently none). You could change the “it’s complicated category to fit one of them.
Bourriks on
In France, it’s one republic, but in the facts, it’s Paris deciding for „all other coutryside peasants“, and teh peasants are really sick of that.
caiaphas8 on
The U.K. is not complicated, it’s just a unitary state, with 3 semi-autonomous region
Chogolatine on
I’d very much say that Belgian case is complicated
Defiant-Dare1223 on
For me Belgium, Germany and Austria aren’t really federal. If you can’t set tax locally, localism is just window dressing.
All the major taxes are centrally set.
I’d say it’s complicated : they lack key federal qualities. They aren’t that different to say UK counties.
Switzerland is really the only genuinely federal state in Western Europe. It claims to be a confederation but isn’t.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
17 Kommentare
Why is the situation „complicated“ in Greece?
Curious if usa would be blue or yellow
What is the complicating aspect of Netherlands?
I would argue that calling Russia federal post-2013 is not true
https://www.reuters.com/article/world/putin-signs-law-to-allow-him-to-pick-russian-governors-idUSBRE9310GR/
Europe doing federal vs unitary like it’s a fashion trend lol
Italy is formally unitary but highly decentralised to its regions.
Just because Russia calls itself a federal state, doesn’t mean its true
Stop with this ridiculous “it’s complicated” label.
If the UK is in the „It’s comlicated“ category then I would argue that Denmark should be so as well, as it’s a pretty similar situation with Greenland and the Faroes Islands being autonomous territories of the Kingdom of Denmark
Too simplistic.
Spain is deliberately ambiguous in its constitution. Switzerland I think might be a confederacy, don’t know the details. Bosnia-Herzegovina is none of the above due to still having a UN representative holding certain powers i.e. not even fully sovereign state in its own right…
Metropolitan France is a unitary state. But New Caledonia and French Polynesia are integral parts of France and suddenly France is a Federal state with 3 quite autonomous subdivisions…
Had to think for a while what makes Finland so complicated. I guess it’s Åland.
On a technical level, there are four categories Unitary (most states), Devolved (UK), Federal (Germany, the US, Australia etc) and Confederation (Currently none). You could change the “it’s complicated category to fit one of them.
In France, it’s one republic, but in the facts, it’s Paris deciding for „all other coutryside peasants“, and teh peasants are really sick of that.
The U.K. is not complicated, it’s just a unitary state, with 3 semi-autonomous region
I’d very much say that Belgian case is complicated
For me Belgium, Germany and Austria aren’t really federal. If you can’t set tax locally, localism is just window dressing.
All the major taxes are centrally set.
I’d say it’s complicated : they lack key federal qualities. They aren’t that different to say UK counties.
Switzerland is really the only genuinely federal state in Western Europe. It claims to be a confederation but isn’t.