Close Menu
    Technik

    Amerikaner verlieren möglicherweise das Vertrauen in KI im Gesundheitswesen

    Share.
    View 41 Comments

    41 Kommentare

    2. Even_Package_8573 on

      The scary part isn’t AI itself, it’s people treating it like it can replace medical professionals. That gap between “helpful tool” and “decision maker” is huge.

    3. falilth on

      Can’t lose what you never had. Get this garbage out of every system its put in.

    6. EasterEggArt on

      I am sorry, who are these special ed failures that blindly trusted a hallucination machine without any concrete evidence and peer reviewed statistics? Like seriously? We really do live more and more in an age of idiocracy.

      I am genuinely trying to understand and recall an age where we put technology blindly into everything without rigorous testing and reviews for ages before starting. That’s like asking me to become a surgeon. Sure I can do it, but learning on the job is not exactly the criteria we start with, now is it? There are a ton of exams and such and yet…. here we are.

      Yes AI companies will claim they did the testing and training ahead of time, but did we really when we have a massive FOMO issue and race to be the first movers? Did we really do the due diligence or say „fuck it, we are doing it live. Move fast and break some human bodies.“??????

      And for those inevitably saying „actually“, please share the published LLM data and research showing us these LLMs having published their methods and results. Oh wait, those are kept propriatary and secret…. weeeeeelllllllllllllllll

    7. Fair_Blood3176 on

      As if it was trusted to begin. Can’t stand these kinds of headlines.

    8. Dumpsterfire_47 on

      I don’t think we ever had trust in AI. We’ve known what Skynet could do for thirty years. 

    10. Haunterblademoi on

      AI should not be used to give medical advice as a substitute for a human.

    11. _Choose__A_Username_ on

      I had like a mild constipation that MiraLAX easily helped with. AI kept telling me it’s a medical emergency and I should go to the ER. Its alarmist doomsday answers do nothing but freak people out and will likely cause them to spend money they don’t have by getting treatment they don’t need.

    13. Gofunkiertti on

      Like obviously I don’t want an AI involved in any part of approving insurance claims. That’s literally the death panels thing the American Right wing was going on about under Obama’s insurance changes. The fact that has to be said out loud is insane.

      The AI transcription services at GP’s I see as a net positive. I would much prefer my GP actually be looking at me rather then spending the whole visit charting. The error rate is comparable to a regular human and will continue to improve. Obviously setting does matter because accurate transcription is much harder in a noisy ER. My GP uses it (with my permission) and I have preferred his care with it.

      The work in spotting conditions in Radiology is probably a best use case for what AI is genuinely great at which is sorting large amounts of data for patterns. Yes I still want someone to oversee it but in terms of finding problems it’s great.

      Having AI’s for custom robotic prosthetics lets a prosthesis use your actual electronic impulses and create a program that matches your actual body’s need creating a custom personalized input that learns from your body is a fantastic use of it.

      90% of my problem with AI come from who is regulating and who is building it. None of the big tech companies are trustworthy or ethical and basically only Europe is doing reasonable government oversights. I would be so much happier with these advancements if I thought they were being developed with more moral foresight.

    14. blah_don_blah on

      I’m just tired of AI being shove in our faces for everything. How many people actually want it everywhere? Because the general consensus on reddit seems like it’s disliked.

    15. SquishTheProgrammer on

      Google’s AI search was literally telling people to drink bleach at one point. I think the trust in AI for healthcare ship sailed a LONG time ago.

    18. GadreelsSword on

      It’s really fucking simple. AI will provide shittier healthcare, and the corporations will make more money.

      You lose, they win. That’s the formula for our future.

    21. joepez on

      So the headline is deliberately misleading. Doctors, and any healthcare providers, are not using AI for their decision making. This is called out in the middle of the article. The article is actually about patients using AI which is extremely risky for anything beyond research. AI has no ability to properly interpret results or do diagnose beyond pulling up website data on a medication, treatment or diagnosis and of course citing sources. People are “talking” to AI believing it’s actually having a conversation with them. 

      AI has lots of uses in healthcare just not in diagnosing patients. 

    25. Bignholy on

      „Stupid Americans catch on to what Sane Americans warned them about a decade ago“

    27. AntiYourOpinion on

      I don’t know a single person that’s trusted AI for their healthcare.

    30. iuffxguy on

      AI is not going anywhere in healthcare. We just need to do better at regulating where it can be used and how it can be used. I actually had a positive experience for my specific use case a couple weeks ago. Went to the ER for something. They did a bunch of blood work and chest xrays within minutes of me getting to the ER and then put me in the waiting room for 6 hours before I could talk to a dr. Meanwhile my app was showing me the results as they came in. I took all of them, along with the data from my garmin, Strava, Apple health and fed it all to Claude and asked its opinion about the test results. It walked me through everything and explained what likely would happen next. When I finally got to the doctor he literally did exactly what Claude said he would do and and explained why he couldn’t do some things (which Claude also warned me about) and then prescribed the exact drugs that Claude said they would. It was very helpful to have Claude explain to me what was going on in a moment of my life that I was scared and had no idea what was happening to me. Claude was honest about my symptoms and didnt sugar coat anything. So in this specific use case it was very valuable. (I dont work for anthropic… ).

    31. ovirt001 on

      Turns out beta testing things in production doesn’t work for healthcare…

    35. GoldBond007 on

      I 100% blame the leaders of industry for being so out of touch with reality that they were sold the illusion of AI.

      Could it be everything that’s promised? Absolutely, with more time and the development of quantum computing. It’s not ready to take over core functions of people yet.

      At best, it must be used as an assistant whose work needs to be double checked before believed.

    37. Jgusdaddy on

      AI will inevitably be used to drive a wedge between patients and the actual morality of human healtcare workers. What is stopping AI from simply billing everyone their life savings for a simple arm cast application? Like, who is going to represent people agains hospitals and health insurance companies? Nothing is stopping them from bankrupting everyone unless we have a revolution and universal healthcare.

    38. monkeypickle8 on

      Who had trust in the first place? I need a list of easy people to scam.

    Leave A Reply