Angenommen, dies wäre eine Szene auf einer Straße in der Schweiz – wer hätte Vorfahrt, dh in welcher Reihenfolge dürften die Autos fahren?
Beschreibung:
- A (rosa) und C (gelb) biegen beide nach links ab
- B (blau) geht geradeaus
Ich möchte es nicht weiter beschreiben, da dies Einfluss darauf haben könnte, wie ich die Situation sehe.
https://i.redd.it/7wx1e5albxrg1.png
Von 77sxela
20 Kommentare
B then C then A. if no signes then the car on the right has right of way, if 3 cars at the kntersection then the car going straight.
B c a
C A B
Eye contact. First mover.
BCA? Not sure… empirically.
This is a Trick question. There are no colored cars in Switzerland.
Without A, B would be before C.
But A goes before B and C goes before A.
CAB
Everyone yields to the car in their right, assuming no other markers on the ground, resulting C A B. No?
Here’s my interpretation:
It cannot be solved without someone taking the first step (aka they communicate with hand signs or whatnot).
There are no street signs, neither as sign posts nor on the street (Haifischzähne). Due to this, it’s always right-before-left (is that the term in English? „Rechts vor links“).
And so, if there’d be only B & A, A would be allowed to go first. Doesn’t matter that B goes straight.
Due to A and C turning left, there’s no clear situation.
Usually it’s me, because the others are not showing any intention to move.
B C A
I think this is a question which can be answered by „communicate by hand signs“ or something like that. I think its an answer that can come at the drivers theory test
Unless there are markings on the street or roadsigns indicating a main street, the „priority“ of right applies. And because everyone has someone on its right, drivers should make a sign to whoever goes first.
B,C,A unless the dotted Y is there, then A,B,C
I think the legally correct answer is B AC (right-most goes first, so C has to defer to A, but A has to defer to B), but there’s a significant chance that C would assume they have right-of-way over B, so eye contact is critical. There’s an intersection in my neighborhood (in the US) where this is a routine situation…and the car in C position usually powers through. B would be crazy to risk that, so CBA is probably safest.
In Switzerland, the fundamental rule at an unmarked intersection is „Right before Left“ (priority to the right).
However, this specific scenario involves cars making turns, which introduces additional rules regarding maneuvering and yielding to oncoming traffic:
1. Turning Left (Car A): According to Swiss traffic law (Art. 36, Para 3 of the Swiss Road Traffic Act), when turning left, you must yield to any oncoming traffic that is traveling straight through the intersection or turning right.
2. Turning Right (Car C): Car C is turning right. While generally, vehicles must yield to those on their right, when turning, they have priority over vehicles turning left from the opposite direction.
3. Going Straight (Car B): Car B is proceeding straight through the intersection.
While every intersection should be approached with caution and communication between drivers is key if the situation is ambiguous, the general hierarchy is:
1. Car B (Blue): Has the right of way as it is traveling straight.
2. Car C (Yellow): Generally has priority over Car A because Car A is turning across the path of oncoming traffic.
3. Car A (Pink): Must wait, as it is turning left across the path of oncoming traffic.
Important Note: This assumes there are no traffic signs (like „Stop,“ „Yield,“ or „Main Road“ signs) or traffic lights at the intersection. If such signs exist, they override the „right before left“ rule. Always prioritize signs and signals over general rules of thumb.
have a junction like this near work. Yield to right as there is no signposting.
If there is a car to your right, you wait.
C A B
C B A because C has no car from the right side and has ‚Vortritt‘ over the others.
This comment section is 90% Aargau drivers. Checking who is turning where, if they have a radio on, if it’s a combi, if the driver wears sunglasses. WTF? Priority to the right! Does not matter if the driver is wearing a hat.
In this situation it’s necessary to have eye contact.
The best solution for this would be that A allow B to go ahead.