Yes, it did. And it has some interesting effects. The biggest one being that Americans who have documentation stating that their nth direct ancestor was born in Canada are applying to be Canadian citizens by descent en masse to give them more options (for example, they can escape some of the divisive politics in their country and the violence associated with such division and polarization).
The other effect is that for people who come from countries that restrict dual citizenship, this fuels a new form of reverse birth tourism. While people were talking about Chinese people coming to Canada to give birth to Canadian citizens (thereby creating dual citizens, one of the few forms of dual citizenship that China allows), these dual citizens themselves will be encouraged to engage in reverse birth tourism where they live in Canada, but travel back to China for the sole reason of giving birth to their child to guarantee that said child will be a Chinese citizen, and bring them right back to Canada (previously, before Bill C-3, this practice can only happen for 1 generation, now it can happen to infinite generations if each person lives in Canada for 3 years before having their child abroad).
MadScienti5t on
Anybody got any stats that would help us to understand the implications of this? How many people who were not born in Canada to parents who were Canadian citizens who also were not born in Canada can now apply for citizenship? I can’t imagine there is a huge Canadian diaspora just chomping at the bit to „come home“…
No_Function_7479 on
I am a bit worried for our healthcare. People with existing health issues living in countries without universal healthcare have more incentive to move to Canada than stay where they are.
I am hoping someone in government is doing the math and putting extra cash into the system
akd432 on
How many generations are we talking about here?
Once_a_TQ on
Such a mistake.
CanNeverBeTooHigh on
the government will continue to keep loopholes in immigration to suppress wages and keep existing property prices high. if anyone understands supply and demand it will be carney.
Think_Oven_7487 on
I honestly do not know how much more immigration Canada can handle. The healthcare system, educational system, housing market & job market are all strained enough as is.
mojorific on
Our government doesn’t see how screwed our healthcare is and continues to operate as if nothing is wrong.
The_Gray_Jay on
People have been getting approved and their last ancestor lived here in the 1800s…having both bloodright and birthright citizenship is pretty wild.
EpicProdigy on
The urge to take my almost fluent in french ass to Quebec and vote to secede.
Gumbode345 on
Expand after reducing it first you mean? Which country denies citizenship to children of its own citizens when they were born abroad?
bogue on
This is insane. Weakens our passport not to mention infrastructure issues.
Hour_Significance817 on
It’s not the doom and gloom folks here are predicting.
The number of people that can (and would even care to) apply for citizenship this way is in the thousands. Maybe tens of thousands.
Unless they decide to become productive members of Canadian society by moving here, social benefits are largely off the table for them. EI doesn’t apply unless they’ve worked enough hours in Canada. OAS doesn’t kick in unless one has lived in Canada for ten years. Provincial healthcare only kicks in six months after establishing residency. Consular services aren’t free, and let’s face it, in comparison to the consular reach of what the US and EU countries can offer for their citizens, Canada’s is at best mediocre.
Going forward, until the rules change, there will be limitations to how citizenship by descent can be passed on i.e. first generation no questions asked, second generation and further generations if one parent has cumulatively lived in Canada for a non-trivial amount of time.
HowlingWolven on
Everyone acting like the sky is falling.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
14 Kommentare
Yes, it did. And it has some interesting effects. The biggest one being that Americans who have documentation stating that their nth direct ancestor was born in Canada are applying to be Canadian citizens by descent en masse to give them more options (for example, they can escape some of the divisive politics in their country and the violence associated with such division and polarization).
The other effect is that for people who come from countries that restrict dual citizenship, this fuels a new form of reverse birth tourism. While people were talking about Chinese people coming to Canada to give birth to Canadian citizens (thereby creating dual citizens, one of the few forms of dual citizenship that China allows), these dual citizens themselves will be encouraged to engage in reverse birth tourism where they live in Canada, but travel back to China for the sole reason of giving birth to their child to guarantee that said child will be a Chinese citizen, and bring them right back to Canada (previously, before Bill C-3, this practice can only happen for 1 generation, now it can happen to infinite generations if each person lives in Canada for 3 years before having their child abroad).
Anybody got any stats that would help us to understand the implications of this? How many people who were not born in Canada to parents who were Canadian citizens who also were not born in Canada can now apply for citizenship? I can’t imagine there is a huge Canadian diaspora just chomping at the bit to „come home“…
I am a bit worried for our healthcare. People with existing health issues living in countries without universal healthcare have more incentive to move to Canada than stay where they are.
I am hoping someone in government is doing the math and putting extra cash into the system
How many generations are we talking about here?
Such a mistake.
the government will continue to keep loopholes in immigration to suppress wages and keep existing property prices high. if anyone understands supply and demand it will be carney.
I honestly do not know how much more immigration Canada can handle. The healthcare system, educational system, housing market & job market are all strained enough as is.
Our government doesn’t see how screwed our healthcare is and continues to operate as if nothing is wrong.
People have been getting approved and their last ancestor lived here in the 1800s…having both bloodright and birthright citizenship is pretty wild.
The urge to take my almost fluent in french ass to Quebec and vote to secede.
Expand after reducing it first you mean? Which country denies citizenship to children of its own citizens when they were born abroad?
This is insane. Weakens our passport not to mention infrastructure issues.
It’s not the doom and gloom folks here are predicting.
The number of people that can (and would even care to) apply for citizenship this way is in the thousands. Maybe tens of thousands.
Unless they decide to become productive members of Canadian society by moving here, social benefits are largely off the table for them. EI doesn’t apply unless they’ve worked enough hours in Canada. OAS doesn’t kick in unless one has lived in Canada for ten years. Provincial healthcare only kicks in six months after establishing residency. Consular services aren’t free, and let’s face it, in comparison to the consular reach of what the US and EU countries can offer for their citizens, Canada’s is at best mediocre.
Going forward, until the rules change, there will be limitations to how citizenship by descent can be passed on i.e. first generation no questions asked, second generation and further generations if one parent has cumulatively lived in Canada for a non-trivial amount of time.
Everyone acting like the sky is falling.