Was mich daran am meisten fasziniert, ist, wie eng einige der territorialen Trennungen der Stämme an der Grenze zwischen den USA und Mexiko im Vergleich zur modernen Grenze beieinander liegen.
whilst the map does note that the edges are fuzzy, they are still sharp enough to give off the impression of understood borders, and in some cases it just misses the mark entirely, such as the land of the Miami (myaamia) not including their capitol (kiihkayonki, modern day fort Wayne Indiana).
I wonder if the places that have many names close together have the better resources?
Norwester77 on
Some of these categories (like Kalapuya, Pomo, Miwok, and Yokuts) are actually small language families, not individual tribes/nations/ethnicities.
JohnnieTango on
I get the point of this map and all and appreciate it. However, something to remember is that the idea of a „nation“ is a European Enlightenment/19th century concept that has been gradually adopted out by the non-Western world.
Not to be too pedantic, but this is really better thought of as a tribal map.
Key-Medicine733 on
Wut happened?
Beneficial_Foot_436 on
Where is Cherokee? map seems off.
edit: ah found them….map still has their range off according to family
bikes_rock_books on
It really should say „North“ American
MagicalTrev0r on
Crazy how this 1500s is so different and more fractured than 1000s America. Truly a collapse of so many great societies, shout out [The Mississippian.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mississippian_culture)
They built structures in Souther Illinois the size of the Great Pyramids. Largely forgotten.
bluesmaker on
I would love to see this kind of thing alongside a set of high quality illustrations that show some aspects of life in various tribes. Like our view of native Americans historically is generally pretty flat. So illustrations are an interesting way to convey some of the differences in clothing, culture, way of life and so on.
JudasWasJesus on
What years? Im oneida this is very skewed?
Xanosaur on
In Vancouver, you have Tsleil-Waututh and Musqueam literally covering Squamish reserves. the map is not very accurate
Graceful_Trekker on
These maps are very wrong.
brigitanti on
Whoa, fuzzy borders make total sense for those fluid tribal histories. Mind blown.
nwbrown on
They are close to real boundaries because they follow natural boundaries and a lot of them are made up.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
17 Kommentare
Make this higher resolution plz
Source?
whilst the map does note that the edges are fuzzy, they are still sharp enough to give off the impression of understood borders, and in some cases it just misses the mark entirely, such as the land of the Miami (myaamia) not including their capitol (kiihkayonki, modern day fort Wayne Indiana).
it’s not *bad*, however
a slightly better map: https://native-land.ca/
Alll gone
I wonder if the places that have many names close together have the better resources?
Some of these categories (like Kalapuya, Pomo, Miwok, and Yokuts) are actually small language families, not individual tribes/nations/ethnicities.
I get the point of this map and all and appreciate it. However, something to remember is that the idea of a „nation“ is a European Enlightenment/19th century concept that has been gradually adopted out by the non-Western world.
Not to be too pedantic, but this is really better thought of as a tribal map.
Wut happened?
Where is Cherokee? map seems off.
edit: ah found them….map still has their range off according to family
It really should say „North“ American
Crazy how this 1500s is so different and more fractured than 1000s America. Truly a collapse of so many great societies, shout out [The Mississippian.](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mississippian_culture)
They built structures in Souther Illinois the size of the Great Pyramids. Largely forgotten.
I would love to see this kind of thing alongside a set of high quality illustrations that show some aspects of life in various tribes. Like our view of native Americans historically is generally pretty flat. So illustrations are an interesting way to convey some of the differences in clothing, culture, way of life and so on.
What years? Im oneida this is very skewed?
In Vancouver, you have Tsleil-Waututh and Musqueam literally covering Squamish reserves. the map is not very accurate
These maps are very wrong.
Whoa, fuzzy borders make total sense for those fluid tribal histories. Mind blown.
They are close to real boundaries because they follow natural boundaries and a lot of them are made up.