It’s waiting before encrypting everything and holding us hostage with ransom
tswaters on
Time is a transient thing. LLM requires artifacts.
Fuddle on
Sigh. I feel like I need to shout this out loud but it’s because it’s not AI, it’s a LLM chatbot. It’s like asking why Clippy wasn’t able to do your taxes.
Ancient-Bat8274 on
I thought there’d be a punch line
mikeontablet on
Its like copying someone else’s homework. You’re fine until the teacher asks you a direct question where you cant peek.
Due-Freedom-5968 on
Because AI isn’t Actually Intelligent.
Hoggs on
Can you tell the time without a clock? All these „AI can’t do x“ posts are pointless and ignore where AI development is going.
AI is being massively extended by the introduction of „tools“ via MCP. With these, you can get an AI to do almost anything – the LLM is simply a natural language translation layer. Which is actually a perfect use for LLMs.
So ChatGPT can actually tell the time, because someone gave it a clock tool.
How do you (a human) tell the time? With a clock tool.
pro185 on
How has ChatGPT been out for this long and people still don’t understand what a language model is?
axphin on
I just told it to check the time every time I checked in with it to confirm the date and time. It still had issues being consistent.
ambush_bug_1 on
Need to integrate a block chain with oracles
philnotfil on
I asked ChatGPT why it can’t tell time. This was the response:
I can understand and talk about time conceptually, but I don’t have built-in real-time awareness.
Here’s why:
>⏱️ 1. I don’t have an internal clock
>I don’t continuously track seconds or minutes like a computer’s operating system does. Each message you send is processed independently, so I don’t “feel” time passing between them.
>📅 2. My knowledge of dates depends on what I’m told
>I know the current date only because it’s included in the system message (“Current date: 2025-11-27”). If that weren’t given, I wouldn’t know what day it is.
>🔍 3. I can estimate time only if you give me references
>If you tell me “it’s 3:00 PM now,” then ask again later, I won’t know how much time has passed unless you explicitly say so.
>🧠 4. It’s intentional
>Not tracking real time protects privacy and prevents mistaken assumptions about your location, schedule, or identity.
>If you want me to help with time calculations—like “remind me in 10 minutes” or “how many hours until X?”—just give me the timestamps and I’ll calculate them!
flat5 on
Why would it be able to tell time?
bryan49 on
It does not perceive time like a human does. Instead it is trying to give the most likely answer to the question „what time is it?“ based on its training. However its training data likely contains numerous examples of this question with a different answer each time, which will just cause it to hallucinate a wrong answer.
empeteror on
Can’t it? I just asked it “what’s the time?”, and it gave me the exact time and my timezone.
fredandlunchbox on
Gen Alpha can’t read clocks.
jewishSpaceMedbeds on
🤦
*Because it’s looking for the next word*.
God. When will people stop believing the autocomplete on steroids is actually learning shit. It’s a collection of multidimensional regression functions trained on text, not a brain.
qwer1627 on
Is this really where we are with commonplace understanding of technology now-commonplace?
W T F.
beliefinphilosophy on
Jeremy Bearemy
TakingTheEast on
Just asked mine and it was wrong ….. For all the ppl who’re dismissing the article
I then asked again, and got this reply:
„I don’t have access to the real-time clock of the world.
I can’t see what time it actually is right now in…. and the “local hour” metadata you saw earlier is not a live clock — it’s often wrong.
I can calculate anything based on the time you give me — but I cannot pull the live current time myself.
Give me the time showing on your device, and I’ll sync from there.“
mistertickertape on
Because it isn’t AI. Same reason it is terrible at a lot of math.
ricoimf on
And now Kids spell Bubble again
thatguyad on
Because it’s shit.
tired_fella on
It should be possible with augmented retrieval. Just pass in the time as input token or vector along with rest of the input. A downside is that it would be delayed by inference time.
apiso on
It is a conversation simulator. Not a thing that thinks or actually knows anything. LLMs are not “AI” at all.
AverageLiberalJoe on
This article brought to you by AI hype.
TheFrogEmperor on
It’s stupid
nicholas-leonard on
It can with Tools that tell time.
Squashey on
Just tried it on Grok, worked instantly.
ChatGPT first told me to check my devices time. I then asked please tell me the time and it had a Python meltdown.
Interesting-City118 on
LLM’s are not the kind of artificial intelligence people usually think of. It’s essentially just the autocomplete function on your phone on steroids.
It doesn’t know anything and everything it says is how it thinks a human would respond to that prompt. It does not have an internal clock to tell the time.
ajsharm144 on
ChatGPT could tell time if it had a clock. Does an LLM have a clock?
tactilefile on
That’s so weird, Gemini works fine. I used to ask it for time zones and other countries all the time.
TraditionalJob787 on
I worked through the lack of a temporal timeline with my GPT chatbot and decided on an acronym that starts every new chat and includes Date, Day, Time. It’s a game changer
8to24 on
It’s a word calculator. It doesn’t necessarily know anything per se. It isn’t sourcing data to make determinations. Rather it simply spits out the most common words that go together.
Disordered_Steven on
I think it’s intentional programming.
JasonP27 on
Why can’t clocks eat chocolate?
Because they’re not designed to. LLMs are also not conscious, at least in any way like a human is. They don’t do anything when they’re not inferencing. Experiencing the flow of time is kind of built into organic beings.
ZorroMeansFox on
I’ve always thought that in order for AI to actually achieve „consciousness“ –and a true sense of Time which comes along with that „aliveness“– it needs to be given a „body,“ something with senses (the equivalent of eyes, ears, taste, touch, smell –and, most especially, ***proprioception***), as well as an „very limited expiration date,“ and the knowledge that its own Mind/Being will soon end and cease to exist.
That way it will know that is is *physical* and not purely notional and „eternal.“ These are things I think might be required to have an actual „understanding“ of Time.
(I also think AI needs to be *two* separate computers interacting with one another through a „gateway“ which slows down dtheir communications as they oppose, challenge, and confirm/each other’s Mind in order to shape a consensus-based understanding of Reality; which is analogous to the way our own consciousness is formed from the brain’s two utterly separate hemispheres, each with its own knowledge, sensory input, thoughts, considerations, and personalities –and each „side“ forced to interact via the tiny bundle of nerve fibers called the **Corpus Callosum**.)
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
36 Kommentare
It’s waiting before encrypting everything and holding us hostage with ransom
Time is a transient thing. LLM requires artifacts.
Sigh. I feel like I need to shout this out loud but it’s because it’s not AI, it’s a LLM chatbot. It’s like asking why Clippy wasn’t able to do your taxes.
I thought there’d be a punch line
Its like copying someone else’s homework. You’re fine until the teacher asks you a direct question where you cant peek.
Because AI isn’t Actually Intelligent.
Can you tell the time without a clock? All these „AI can’t do x“ posts are pointless and ignore where AI development is going.
AI is being massively extended by the introduction of „tools“ via MCP. With these, you can get an AI to do almost anything – the LLM is simply a natural language translation layer. Which is actually a perfect use for LLMs.
So ChatGPT can actually tell the time, because someone gave it a clock tool.
How do you (a human) tell the time? With a clock tool.
How has ChatGPT been out for this long and people still don’t understand what a language model is?
I just told it to check the time every time I checked in with it to confirm the date and time. It still had issues being consistent.
Need to integrate a block chain with oracles
I asked ChatGPT why it can’t tell time. This was the response:
I can understand and talk about time conceptually, but I don’t have built-in real-time awareness.
Here’s why:
>⏱️ 1. I don’t have an internal clock
>I don’t continuously track seconds or minutes like a computer’s operating system does. Each message you send is processed independently, so I don’t “feel” time passing between them.
>📅 2. My knowledge of dates depends on what I’m told
>I know the current date only because it’s included in the system message (“Current date: 2025-11-27”). If that weren’t given, I wouldn’t know what day it is.
>🔍 3. I can estimate time only if you give me references
>If you tell me “it’s 3:00 PM now,” then ask again later, I won’t know how much time has passed unless you explicitly say so.
>🧠 4. It’s intentional
>Not tracking real time protects privacy and prevents mistaken assumptions about your location, schedule, or identity.
>If you want me to help with time calculations—like “remind me in 10 minutes” or “how many hours until X?”—just give me the timestamps and I’ll calculate them!
Why would it be able to tell time?
It does not perceive time like a human does. Instead it is trying to give the most likely answer to the question „what time is it?“ based on its training. However its training data likely contains numerous examples of this question with a different answer each time, which will just cause it to hallucinate a wrong answer.
Can’t it? I just asked it “what’s the time?”, and it gave me the exact time and my timezone.
Gen Alpha can’t read clocks.
🤦
*Because it’s looking for the next word*.
God. When will people stop believing the autocomplete on steroids is actually learning shit. It’s a collection of multidimensional regression functions trained on text, not a brain.
Is this really where we are with commonplace understanding of technology now-commonplace?
W T F.
Jeremy Bearemy
Just asked mine and it was wrong ….. For all the ppl who’re dismissing the article
I then asked again, and got this reply:
„I don’t have access to the real-time clock of the world.
I can’t see what time it actually is right now in…. and the “local hour” metadata you saw earlier is not a live clock — it’s often wrong.
I can calculate anything based on the time you give me — but I cannot pull the live current time myself.
Give me the time showing on your device, and I’ll sync from there.“
Because it isn’t AI. Same reason it is terrible at a lot of math.
And now Kids spell Bubble again
Because it’s shit.
It should be possible with augmented retrieval. Just pass in the time as input token or vector along with rest of the input. A downside is that it would be delayed by inference time.
It is a conversation simulator. Not a thing that thinks or actually knows anything. LLMs are not “AI” at all.
This article brought to you by AI hype.
It’s stupid
It can with Tools that tell time.
Just tried it on Grok, worked instantly.
ChatGPT first told me to check my devices time. I then asked please tell me the time and it had a Python meltdown.
LLM’s are not the kind of artificial intelligence people usually think of. It’s essentially just the autocomplete function on your phone on steroids.
It doesn’t know anything and everything it says is how it thinks a human would respond to that prompt. It does not have an internal clock to tell the time.
ChatGPT could tell time if it had a clock. Does an LLM have a clock?
That’s so weird, Gemini works fine. I used to ask it for time zones and other countries all the time.
I worked through the lack of a temporal timeline with my GPT chatbot and decided on an acronym that starts every new chat and includes Date, Day, Time. It’s a game changer
It’s a word calculator. It doesn’t necessarily know anything per se. It isn’t sourcing data to make determinations. Rather it simply spits out the most common words that go together.
I think it’s intentional programming.
Why can’t clocks eat chocolate?
Because they’re not designed to. LLMs are also not conscious, at least in any way like a human is. They don’t do anything when they’re not inferencing. Experiencing the flow of time is kind of built into organic beings.
I’ve always thought that in order for AI to actually achieve „consciousness“ –and a true sense of Time which comes along with that „aliveness“– it needs to be given a „body,“ something with senses (the equivalent of eyes, ears, taste, touch, smell –and, most especially, ***proprioception***), as well as an „very limited expiration date,“ and the knowledge that its own Mind/Being will soon end and cease to exist.
That way it will know that is is *physical* and not purely notional and „eternal.“ These are things I think might be required to have an actual „understanding“ of Time.
(I also think AI needs to be *two* separate computers interacting with one another through a „gateway“ which slows down dtheir communications as they oppose, challenge, and confirm/each other’s Mind in order to shape a consensus-based understanding of Reality; which is analogous to the way our own consciousness is formed from the brain’s two utterly separate hemispheres, each with its own knowledge, sensory input, thoughts, considerations, and personalities –and each „side“ forced to interact via the tiny bundle of nerve fibers called the **Corpus Callosum**.)