Data: 2019-2023 American Community Survey accessed via API using tidycensus package in R
Tools: R (packages: dplyr, ggplot2, sf, usmap, tools, ggfx, grid, scales)
PM_ME_YOUR_SAD_ROBOT on
Literally every single data map of the US looks like this
blahyawnblah on
Funny thing about oregon is that percentage is about the same as the percent of people that graduate high school.
I exaggerate, but it’s bad.
eatingpotatochips on
Probably an instance where excluding DC would be appropriate, since it is just an urban area, whereas even states like MA have some areas which aren’t urban.
ruleConformUserName on
Why the high percentage in big bend, Texas?
MasterOfBarterTown on
Wyoming exports kids, many after getting a degree. A lot of those end up on the front range of Colorado.
hodd01 on
every one of this map post is really just a poverty/racial map
njm147 on
Virginia is one the more suprising ones
SunDevilSkier on
Huntsville pushing Alabama off the bottom of the list
thatoneredheadgirl on
I don’t know why but I expected the numbers to be higher
MoltenMate07 on
When did Colorado become so great regarding median income and education?
-AbeFroman on
I live in Colorado and thought „that’s weird Wyoming is so high“.
Anthnytdwg on
I might take this and overlay it with the voting map. Very curious.
DeceptiveGold57 on
This chart doesn’t factor in associates degrees and trade schools, which are perfectly acceptable forms of education.
MasterOfBarterTown on
I see a lot of this due to the influx of young, degreed people from other states. So, Illinois has the Chicago financial industry. Colorado has Denver and its outliers. Utah has a lifestyle location to draw programmers, etc. Virginia – college centers and US Federal workers? Georgia has HBCU grads relocating to Atlanta? Massachusetts has finance and insurance (and more – as well as the nation’s leader in secondary education outcomes).
But why is Vermont’s percentage so high? Also, the same question applies to Minnesota (I’m assuming a lifestyle choice which helps businesses recruit).
mathers33 on
And that’s why Colorado and Virginia are blue states now
Andronixx on
In other words, places with a high concentration of jobs requiring college degrees have more people with college degrees – go figure
I-Like-Women-Boobs on
As someone who regularly visits West Virginia and has a lot of family there, it’s not surprising in the slightest that they’re at the bottom.
Next_Ad_9281 on
Notice how all the states with the least educated folks vote red?
Description_Capable on
Interesting data, but let’s be honest about what this actually shows vs what people want it to show.
First off, having a bachelor’s degree doesn’t equal intelligence or wisdom. Plenty of brilliant people go into trades, start businesses, or join the military instead of racking up college debt. Mike Rowe’s been saying this for years – we’ve oversold college and undersold skilled trades.
Second, look at the county map – even ‚uneducated‘ red states have highly educated urban cores. The divide isn’t really red vs blue states, it’s urban vs rural. Cities require degrees for most jobs while rural areas need farmers, mechanics, and tradespeople. Different economies, different needs.
Funny how several of these ‚highly educated‘ states (Colorado, Mass, DC) were also first to legalize pot. Makes you wonder if all that education just taught them how to rationalize getting high. Or maybe they needed something to cope with their student loan payments.
The real issue? We’re watching massive brain drain from rural to urban America, leaving behind communities that built this country. Instead of smugly pointing at education maps, maybe we should ask why we’ve created an economy where young people have to leave their hometowns to succeed.
Also correlation isn’t causation – college grads concentrate in expensive cities because that’s where their degrees actually matter. Different lifestyle, different politics.
KingKnowles on
I graduated as the valedictorian of my high school in Arkansas which provided me tuition free college (from Walmart – they made us write yearly thank you letters) at an Arkansas state college. I am grateful for that!
As soon as I graduated with my bachelor’s degree, I jumped on a plane and moved to Maryland. That has been one of the best decision of my life!
Have we looked at the exported data? People with a bachelor’s or higher leaving the state?
Leucippus1 on
Colorado only has 5 million people, it is a state with large numbers of tech engineers and mining/ag engineering, so that inflates us a bit in percentages.
Miqo_Nekomancer on
Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama are all remaining true to form, I see.
kodex1717 on
Something tells me that DC would probably be in-line with other Northeastern cities if you considered only the municipal boundary, not the state.
RagefireHype on
I’m gonna be honest, this seems really high even for the low states. Do even 30% of adults above 18 go to college, let alone graduate?
PimpOfJoytime on
Jesus you’d be a bonafide genius in Arkansas with a Masters in anything.
Salt_Principle_6672 on
It’s THAT LOW?????? No wonder we’re in the mess we’re in jeeze
eta_carinae_311 on
San Miguel county is where Telluride is located and Pitkin has Aspen, which are both known rich people places but I’m still kind of surprised to see them in the top 10. You’d think Boulder at least would have made it, I wonder if it’s because of the university and how many people are students not graduates? interesting
zAbso on
This chart is probably a bit misleading. I grew up in the south and got a bachelors degree in computer science. I moved out west after graduating since that’s where the job market is.
I also know a lot of people that graduated with bachelors and masters that did the same. Plenty of educated people there, but you have to go where the market is for the degree you have.
txa1265 on
Could have added the (25 – 30%) and had bottom as <25% – but otherwise like this pair!
ConfidentSuspect4125 on
Interesting that this map is almost a duplicate of politicial red and blue states. I wonder which ones are most educated?
scott__p on
I like how you can easily find the rural universities on the county map
The_Smoking_Pilot on
I love the trend of showing us maps where the south is always the shittiest by every quantifiable metric
whydid7eat9 on
I have always thought people in one of those yellow states were dumber than average, and now I have proof!
Jenny_Saint_Quan on
All the people getting a bachelors degree in Lousiana are leaving the state for better jobs
Darkwolfie117 on
That’s a lot more then I thought, no wonder schools are rich
agentoutlier on
My wife and I live in Boston suburb and we feel below average with our bachelors degrees. (I wanted to go back but decided to start a business).
Every one of our neighbors has like a masters or higher.
The state makes you feel like a pariah if you do not have a degree.
TotheMoonorGrounded on
Hmm this is way lower than I expected
ChalkButter on
Yeah, that map is about what I expected
mking22 on
From a yellow county in WV and have a bachelors degree, AMA
OverflowDs on
If I was you, I would use the 1 year estimates for state level estimates. They are more recent and reliable enough at the state level.
figgypudding531 on
That’s honestly lower than I thought it would be
tyen0 on
I was flabbergasted that it was only 1/3 of the country but when I saw that it was 2/3 of my county, I guess it explains my confusion.
I also find 25 as the age cut off interesting since most people should get it at 21/22 (4 years after high school) but I was in that cohort that took longer due to working full time and college part time.
_dirt_vonnegut on
DC is not a state (contrary to the legend), and not identified on the map (like all other states). The data is not beautiful.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
46 Kommentare
Data: 2019-2023 American Community Survey accessed via API using tidycensus package in R
Tools: R (packages: dplyr, ggplot2, sf, usmap, tools, ggfx, grid, scales)
Literally every single data map of the US looks like this
Funny thing about oregon is that percentage is about the same as the percent of people that graduate high school.
I exaggerate, but it’s bad.
Probably an instance where excluding DC would be appropriate, since it is just an urban area, whereas even states like MA have some areas which aren’t urban.
Why the high percentage in big bend, Texas?
Wyoming exports kids, many after getting a degree. A lot of those end up on the front range of Colorado.
every one of this map post is really just a poverty/racial map
Virginia is one the more suprising ones
Huntsville pushing Alabama off the bottom of the list
I don’t know why but I expected the numbers to be higher
When did Colorado become so great regarding median income and education?
I live in Colorado and thought „that’s weird Wyoming is so high“.
I might take this and overlay it with the voting map. Very curious.
This chart doesn’t factor in associates degrees and trade schools, which are perfectly acceptable forms of education.
I see a lot of this due to the influx of young, degreed people from other states. So, Illinois has the Chicago financial industry. Colorado has Denver and its outliers. Utah has a lifestyle location to draw programmers, etc. Virginia – college centers and US Federal workers? Georgia has HBCU grads relocating to Atlanta? Massachusetts has finance and insurance (and more – as well as the nation’s leader in secondary education outcomes).
But why is Vermont’s percentage so high? Also, the same question applies to Minnesota (I’m assuming a lifestyle choice which helps businesses recruit).
And that’s why Colorado and Virginia are blue states now
In other words, places with a high concentration of jobs requiring college degrees have more people with college degrees – go figure
As someone who regularly visits West Virginia and has a lot of family there, it’s not surprising in the slightest that they’re at the bottom.
Notice how all the states with the least educated folks vote red?
Interesting data, but let’s be honest about what this actually shows vs what people want it to show.
First off, having a bachelor’s degree doesn’t equal intelligence or wisdom. Plenty of brilliant people go into trades, start businesses, or join the military instead of racking up college debt. Mike Rowe’s been saying this for years – we’ve oversold college and undersold skilled trades.
Second, look at the county map – even ‚uneducated‘ red states have highly educated urban cores. The divide isn’t really red vs blue states, it’s urban vs rural. Cities require degrees for most jobs while rural areas need farmers, mechanics, and tradespeople. Different economies, different needs.
Funny how several of these ‚highly educated‘ states (Colorado, Mass, DC) were also first to legalize pot. Makes you wonder if all that education just taught them how to rationalize getting high. Or maybe they needed something to cope with their student loan payments.
The real issue? We’re watching massive brain drain from rural to urban America, leaving behind communities that built this country. Instead of smugly pointing at education maps, maybe we should ask why we’ve created an economy where young people have to leave their hometowns to succeed.
Also correlation isn’t causation – college grads concentrate in expensive cities because that’s where their degrees actually matter. Different lifestyle, different politics.
I graduated as the valedictorian of my high school in Arkansas which provided me tuition free college (from Walmart – they made us write yearly thank you letters) at an Arkansas state college. I am grateful for that!
As soon as I graduated with my bachelor’s degree, I jumped on a plane and moved to Maryland. That has been one of the best decision of my life!
https://preview.redd.it/1i1rpoezf6qf1.png?width=1366&format=png&auto=webp&s=1873ae85658b719fcb8e9719f4bd6c32a905a742
Very strongly correlates to:
Have we looked at the exported data? People with a bachelor’s or higher leaving the state?
Colorado only has 5 million people, it is a state with large numbers of tech engineers and mining/ag engineering, so that inflates us a bit in percentages.
Oklahoma, Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, and Alabama are all remaining true to form, I see.
Something tells me that DC would probably be in-line with other Northeastern cities if you considered only the municipal boundary, not the state.
I’m gonna be honest, this seems really high even for the low states. Do even 30% of adults above 18 go to college, let alone graduate?
Jesus you’d be a bonafide genius in Arkansas with a Masters in anything.
It’s THAT LOW?????? No wonder we’re in the mess we’re in jeeze
San Miguel county is where Telluride is located and Pitkin has Aspen, which are both known rich people places but I’m still kind of surprised to see them in the top 10. You’d think Boulder at least would have made it, I wonder if it’s because of the university and how many people are students not graduates? interesting
This chart is probably a bit misleading. I grew up in the south and got a bachelors degree in computer science. I moved out west after graduating since that’s where the job market is.
I also know a lot of people that graduated with bachelors and masters that did the same. Plenty of educated people there, but you have to go where the market is for the degree you have.
Could have added the (25 – 30%) and had bottom as <25% – but otherwise like this pair!
Interesting that this map is almost a duplicate of politicial red and blue states. I wonder which ones are most educated?
I like how you can easily find the rural universities on the county map
I love the trend of showing us maps where the south is always the shittiest by every quantifiable metric
I have always thought people in one of those yellow states were dumber than average, and now I have proof!
All the people getting a bachelors degree in Lousiana are leaving the state for better jobs
That’s a lot more then I thought, no wonder schools are rich
My wife and I live in Boston suburb and we feel below average with our bachelors degrees. (I wanted to go back but decided to start a business).
Every one of our neighbors has like a masters or higher.
The state makes you feel like a pariah if you do not have a degree.
Hmm this is way lower than I expected
Yeah, that map is about what I expected
From a yellow county in WV and have a bachelors degree, AMA
If I was you, I would use the 1 year estimates for state level estimates. They are more recent and reliable enough at the state level.
That’s honestly lower than I thought it would be
I was flabbergasted that it was only 1/3 of the country but when I saw that it was 2/3 of my county, I guess it explains my confusion.
I also find 25 as the age cut off interesting since most people should get it at 21/22 (4 years after high school) but I was in that cohort that took longer due to working full time and college part time.
DC is not a state (contrary to the legend), and not identified on the map (like all other states). The data is not beautiful.