Hallo allerseits,
Ich verstehe dieses Zeichen nicht. Basierend auf dem Ertragszeichen muss ich allen im Kreisverkehr nachgeben. Warum heißt es, dass die rechte vor der linken Regel gilt?
https://i.redd.it/fqg8lckmeykf1.jpeg
Von Grindelwaldt
Hallo allerseits,
Ich verstehe dieses Zeichen nicht. Basierend auf dem Ertragszeichen muss ich allen im Kreisverkehr nachgeben. Warum heißt es, dass die rechte vor der linken Regel gilt?
https://i.redd.it/fqg8lckmeykf1.jpeg
Von Grindelwaldt
22 Kommentare
Because it’s not a roundabout
It’s a „Verkehrsinsel“ („traffic island“?) Where the car coming from the right always has the right of way (Rechts vor links Regel)
> Based on the yield sign
That’s not a yield sign, that’s a „Gefahrenzeichen“.
EDIT in response to downvotes: Yo, I wrote this BEFORE OP let us know this is all from the Austrian driving laws.
__
I think this is one of those questions you need to report for an error. You must yield to all vehicles in a roundabout which is what that sign means. This illustration makes no sense, you’re so far away still from the roundabout that by the time you get there the tractor will have already passed anyway. You have to also note whether it is signaling a turn. You always give way to the active traffic, and roundabouts are far more about timing and giving yourself enough space, and waiting for a safe option (defensive driving).
That road sign doesn’t exist in Germany. It’s not a „Yield“ sign: the triangle is pointing up, so it’s a warning sign („Warning: roundabout“), one that exists in many European countries but Germany isn’t one of them.
What app is this?
This is Austria right? In that case it’s a tricky question. The roundabout sign give you in Austrian law not the task to wait. But in reality on every entrance of every Austrian roundabout you find a „Vorang geben“. So, in this question you are wrong but in reality you would be right because of the extra sign.
Well done Germany for making something more complicated than it needs to be.
This looks like the images from the Austrian drivers license test. Also the sign is not a German but an Austrian one.
Because this is not a roundabout. It is not marked as such (the blue sign with the circle of arrows is missing). This is a normal right-before-left situation.
It’s a Trick question. I have been living and driving in Germany for all my life and I never came across a situation like that.
In roundabouts, the vehicle inside the roundabouts has always priority. Is logical: if they will need to give priority to vehicles driving inside the roundabouts, the roundabouts will be soon stuck.
Die Szene soll sich sehr wahrscheinlich in Österreich abspielen. Denn in Deutschland gäbe es diese Szene so nicht. Aus der Wikipedia:
„In Österreich ist der Kreisverkehr nach [§ 2](https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Dokumentnummer=NOR40175080) [StVO](https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stra%C3%9Fenverkehrsordnung_(%C3%96sterreich)) „eine kreisförmige oder annähernd kreisförmig verlaufende Fahrbahn, die für den Verkehr in eine Richtung bestimmt ist“. Nach [§ 50](https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/Dokument.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Dokumentnummer=NOR40081328) StVO kann für die *Kreuzung mit Kreisverkehr* das *Symbol 3a* [*Das ist das hier gezeigte*] verwendet werden.
Weitere Regelungen gibt es in der österreichischen StVO nicht, da der Kreisverkehr wie eine normale Kreuzung behandelt wird. Bezüglich des Vorranges kommt es darauf an, ob für die einfahrenden Fahrzeuge das Verkehrszeichen „Vorrang geben“ aufgestellt ist (Wartepflicht für die Einfahrenden – „Kreisverkehr mit Vorrang“) oder nicht (Wartepflicht für die Fahrzeuge im Kreisverkehr nach der Regel „rechts vor links“ – „Kreisverkehr ohne Vorrang“). In den meisten Fällen steht an allen Armen des Kreisverkehrs die Tafel *Vorrang geben*. Es gibt in Österreich jedoch auch Kreisverkehre mit gemischtem Vorrang.“
In unserem Fall steht hier kein Schild mit „Vorrang geben“. Entsprechend ist die App so korrekt und der Einfahrende hat Vorfahrt.
Translation:
The scene is very likely set in Austria. Because in Germany, such a scene would not exist in this way. From Wikipedia:
„In Austria, according to § 2 of the Road Traffic Act (StVO), a roundabout is ‚a circular or approximately circular roadway designated for traffic in one direction.‘ According to § 50 StVO, the symbol 3a [*the one shown here*] can be used for intersections with roundabouts.
There are no further regulations in the Austrian StVO, since the roundabout is treated like a normal intersection. Regarding right of way, it depends on whether the ‚Yield‘ sign is placed for entering vehicles (obligation to wait for those entering – ‚roundabout with right of way‘) or not (obligation to wait for vehicles inside the roundabout according to the ‚priority to the right‘ rule – ‚roundabout without right of way‘). In most cases, a Yield sign is placed at all arms of the roundabout. However, in Austria, there are also roundabouts with mixed right of way.“
In our case, there is no „Yield“ sign. Accordingly, the app is correct, and the vehicle entering has the right of way.
Its a roundabout, you have to give way to everyone inside the roundabout and you are only allowed to turn right and drive counter clockwise.
That’s an Austrian sign, not German.
Austrian here: you have the right of way because there‘s no yield sign (Vorrang geben, the red-white triangle which is upside down compared to this). In this specific case you have the right of way because the tractor is to your left and it‘s like any other unmarked intersection
If there would not be this sign, normally it is right before left. But every roundabout has this sign
This is Austrian, not German.
There’s no yield sign. Yield sign is upside down with no icon on it
Kreisverkehr the cars in the roundabout have ever priority
r/rondpoints
Nobody has mentioned the obvious problem that you’ve somehow travelled back in time. Just look at motorwagen coming at you.
The blue round sign on the island is the key here. It’s not a roundabout, it’s a Verkehrsinsel and the tractor must give you right of way. One of this exists close to my house and a lot of drivers get it wrong.
r/FUCKYOUINPARTICULAR tractor