>The force said the investigation „will be evidence-led and will closely consider all appropriate legislation, including relating to hate crimes“.
We shall see if the court will rule that inciting violence against the IDF (whatever that means) amounts to inciting violence against Jewish people.
Stumblingwanderer on
Let’s all pretend this isn’t purely to placate the Israeli embassy.
nr191 on
I’ve said this elsewhere but I’ll say it again here…
The political class in the U.K. has a terrible record of associating criticism of Israel’s occupational and expansionist policies in Gaza and the West Bank with antisemitism. Likely at the behest of the Zionist lobby and the United States.
This has done nothing but devalue true incidents of antisemitism which is obviously a problem and egregious when it happens.
Explicitly calling out the IDF is not antisemitic and is a shocking insult to many to try and badge this as such.
Paddy3118 on
Hmm, maybe our politicians don’t like being reminded of looking in the mirror and finding themselves wanting.
Annual_History_796 on
Nothing says “underfunded and under-resourced” like spending time and money investigating someone chanting at a concert.
Disastrous-Angle-591 on
How is „Death the IDF“ anti-semitic? They are a militant arm of the Israeli government. They’re not saying „death to jews“ or even „death to Israel“ but „Death to the IDF“ a notoriously ruthless military arm. Wouldn’t be like saying „Death the Paras“ if you were from say Derry in the 70s? Not „Death to the English“ or „England“ but the military force. Help me understand.
Head-Philosopher-721 on
The clown show continues.
Legislating against speech has, shock horror, not decreased bigotry but has increased police work. Stop trying to control people’s views and let the police focus on real crimes.
Harmless_Drone on
„We have received a large amount of contact in relation to these events from people across the world“
Didn’t realize the British police were the world police. Public order offenses now include offending non-british people overseas, it seems.
Lonely-Elephant9999 on
Nothings coming from this, it’s just A&S police being forced to say they’re doing something imo
TuringComplete213 on
Meanwhile israelies can say death to arabs with impunity.
Matt6453 on
Look at the BBC news page and the juxtaposition of the stories, you couldn’t make it up.
LowDare7015 on
I wonder how much pressure our media and political elite are under through back channels from America and isreal to react over this. For me as a normal person…. The OVERWHELMING concensus is that genocide is happening and this was a backlash from a very large group of people in one place, doesn’t this tell our democratically elected leaders to follow what people want?
Just my opinion….
wishbeaunash on
A punk band who’s whole thing is saying controversial political stuff said something mildly controversial at a festival known for left wing polemics. That seems like a truly insane thing for the police to investigate.
roddyhammer on
Not really clear on the law here.
For this to be a criminal act, does the chanting need to be anti-semitic?
Regardless of sentiments toward the IDF (who I have no particular care for), isn’t the potential crime here just the act of incitement to violence/hatred? Doesn’t seem really relevant if its anti-semitic or not.
moon_nicely on
I wonder if JD Vance will be ranting about our free speech.
3bagsfull-Sir8282 on
Murdering innocent hungry children queing for food looks more criminal than some hurty words directed at those ‘killing innocent hungry children queing for food ”( some people are only human/humanists )
Only the great makevelies & manipulators can turn that on its head and claim to be the victims with the help of MSM and politicians who are all complicit in the insidious actions of a states war machince.
Jimrodsdisdain on
So that burglary I suffered three months ago is still not going to be investigated but this shit is?!
Ffs.
No_Aesthetic on
Tens of thousands of innocent people dead in Gaza and they’re worried about this bullshit.
mlthm33 on
So having announced no further action against kneecap they’re opening another investigation into a separate incident, complete waste of time
GiftedGeordie on
This is ridiculous, I understand that antisemitism a very serious issue and should be treated like the hate crime that it is, but when the IDF are committing war crimes against innocent and unarmed civilians, that is something that they should be criticised for!
This is no difference to the distraction politics that the Tories would use when they wanted to draw attention away from their many, many failings as a government. It’s shameful to say that criticising the IDF is antisemitism because that just trivialises actual instances of antisemitism.
Bownzinho on
I know their performances were bad because they’re terrible artists but to get the police involved is a bit harsh.
CJBill on
I’m sure Toby Young and his Free Speech Union will be along to defend them any minute now…
Plasticbonder on
What a waste of time and money – just to pacify the fucking Israelis. Just what is it that they have got on our politicians?
WangNuts on
The government is so out of touch with the country’s sentiment on these issues.
SDLRob on
So… What did Kneecap do this time? The article literally mentions them once.
Scott_Dee89 on
Are they just shoe-horning Kneecap in because they are the whipping boys at the moment? What is there to investigate about their set?
SidneySmut on
“No place for hate” say the police. I mean the IDF has killed how many thousands of children? How many people are being killed each day by the IDF? But no, the bad people are musicians.
redditbattles on
Glastonbury Festival has always been somewhat of a political platform, but fuck I’m glad I’m not there this year, so much virtue signalling and performance politics.
CaptainVaticanus on
Someone shout death to Russian armed forces and see if they investigate that one
OdinLegacy121 on
If you get imprisoned for mean tweets then this has to be investigated with the same brush
moonfarmer89 on
What a joke. Not enough money or officers to deal with crime here but suddenly they can when there’s criticism against a foreign army that’s killing children for entertainment.
UnhappyWolf233 on
Down with the IDF, Zionisim and the Israeli terrorist government regime.
EnderMB on
I’m sure the two politically charged groups against British society are absolutely livid that Avon and Somerset Police are investigating them. I’m sure they’re equally livid that older people are shitting on their music and calling them edge lords.
Honestly, at this point you have to wonder if this is all just PR for both bands. Kneecap literally used the free press as their opening to Glasto, and Bob Vylan will probably get a new record deal, more dates on their tour, and a few million more listeners from all this noise.
Sometimes I wonder what planet some people on here live on. The same arguments seem to rear their heads, as if these punk/rap groups give a fuck if they’ll spend some time in a cell.
xnvrdarren on
I once had a car broken into and was told “what do you think we can do about that?” But it’s stunning to see an investigation into some chanting at a festival
OldGuto on
Oh how times have changed… Those on the left who think „death to the IDF“ is OK have lost the moral authority they once had – because the left once knew words have meaning and there were things you don’t say. If „fuck the IDF“ had been said there wouldn’t have been an issue, some would have grumbled I’m sure but they’d have been told to wind their necks in.
I wonder how many of those on the left who are OK with „death to the IDF“ would be happy with a redneck band singing the same about gays, trans, non-whites etc.?
Edit: Please remember that Glastonbury was traditionally tied to the peace movement – CND and Greenpeace. Performers saying „stop the IDF“, „IDF out of Gaza“, „peace in Palestine“ or „end the occupation“ that’s fine, chanting „death to the IDF“ is very much against the ethos of Glastonbury.
jonxmack on
Where do I email my support for the comments they made on stage?
Squishtakovich on
People take things too literally these days (probably because it suits their agenda). Do they really think that the Glastonbury audience are going to take on the IDF after listening to Bob Vylan?
YassinRs on
May the same treatment that Palestinians get while queuing for aid be inflicted on the IDF.
Leave A Reply
Du musst angemeldet sein, um einen Kommentar abzugeben.
38 Kommentare
>The force said the investigation „will be evidence-led and will closely consider all appropriate legislation, including relating to hate crimes“.
We shall see if the court will rule that inciting violence against the IDF (whatever that means) amounts to inciting violence against Jewish people.
Let’s all pretend this isn’t purely to placate the Israeli embassy.
I’ve said this elsewhere but I’ll say it again here…
The political class in the U.K. has a terrible record of associating criticism of Israel’s occupational and expansionist policies in Gaza and the West Bank with antisemitism. Likely at the behest of the Zionist lobby and the United States.
This has done nothing but devalue true incidents of antisemitism which is obviously a problem and egregious when it happens.
Explicitly calling out the IDF is not antisemitic and is a shocking insult to many to try and badge this as such.
Hmm, maybe our politicians don’t like being reminded of looking in the mirror and finding themselves wanting.
Nothing says “underfunded and under-resourced” like spending time and money investigating someone chanting at a concert.
How is „Death the IDF“ anti-semitic? They are a militant arm of the Israeli government. They’re not saying „death to jews“ or even „death to Israel“ but „Death to the IDF“ a notoriously ruthless military arm. Wouldn’t be like saying „Death the Paras“ if you were from say Derry in the 70s? Not „Death to the English“ or „England“ but the military force. Help me understand.
The clown show continues.
Legislating against speech has, shock horror, not decreased bigotry but has increased police work. Stop trying to control people’s views and let the police focus on real crimes.
„We have received a large amount of contact in relation to these events from people across the world“
Didn’t realize the British police were the world police. Public order offenses now include offending non-british people overseas, it seems.
Nothings coming from this, it’s just A&S police being forced to say they’re doing something imo
Meanwhile israelies can say death to arabs with impunity.
Look at the BBC news page and the juxtaposition of the stories, you couldn’t make it up.
I wonder how much pressure our media and political elite are under through back channels from America and isreal to react over this. For me as a normal person…. The OVERWHELMING concensus is that genocide is happening and this was a backlash from a very large group of people in one place, doesn’t this tell our democratically elected leaders to follow what people want?
Just my opinion….
A punk band who’s whole thing is saying controversial political stuff said something mildly controversial at a festival known for left wing polemics. That seems like a truly insane thing for the police to investigate.
Not really clear on the law here.
For this to be a criminal act, does the chanting need to be anti-semitic?
Regardless of sentiments toward the IDF (who I have no particular care for), isn’t the potential crime here just the act of incitement to violence/hatred? Doesn’t seem really relevant if its anti-semitic or not.
I wonder if JD Vance will be ranting about our free speech.
Murdering innocent hungry children queing for food looks more criminal than some hurty words directed at those ‘killing innocent hungry children queing for food ”( some people are only human/humanists )
Only the great makevelies & manipulators can turn that on its head and claim to be the victims with the help of MSM and politicians who are all complicit in the insidious actions of a states war machince.
So that burglary I suffered three months ago is still not going to be investigated but this shit is?!
Ffs.
Tens of thousands of innocent people dead in Gaza and they’re worried about this bullshit.
So having announced no further action against kneecap they’re opening another investigation into a separate incident, complete waste of time
This is ridiculous, I understand that antisemitism a very serious issue and should be treated like the hate crime that it is, but when the IDF are committing war crimes against innocent and unarmed civilians, that is something that they should be criticised for!
This is no difference to the distraction politics that the Tories would use when they wanted to draw attention away from their many, many failings as a government. It’s shameful to say that criticising the IDF is antisemitism because that just trivialises actual instances of antisemitism.
I know their performances were bad because they’re terrible artists but to get the police involved is a bit harsh.
I’m sure Toby Young and his Free Speech Union will be along to defend them any minute now…
What a waste of time and money – just to pacify the fucking Israelis. Just what is it that they have got on our politicians?
The government is so out of touch with the country’s sentiment on these issues.
So… What did Kneecap do this time? The article literally mentions them once.
Are they just shoe-horning Kneecap in because they are the whipping boys at the moment? What is there to investigate about their set?
“No place for hate” say the police. I mean the IDF has killed how many thousands of children? How many people are being killed each day by the IDF? But no, the bad people are musicians.
Glastonbury Festival has always been somewhat of a political platform, but fuck I’m glad I’m not there this year, so much virtue signalling and performance politics.
Someone shout death to Russian armed forces and see if they investigate that one
If you get imprisoned for mean tweets then this has to be investigated with the same brush
What a joke. Not enough money or officers to deal with crime here but suddenly they can when there’s criticism against a foreign army that’s killing children for entertainment.
Down with the IDF, Zionisim and the Israeli terrorist government regime.
I’m sure the two politically charged groups against British society are absolutely livid that Avon and Somerset Police are investigating them. I’m sure they’re equally livid that older people are shitting on their music and calling them edge lords.
Honestly, at this point you have to wonder if this is all just PR for both bands. Kneecap literally used the free press as their opening to Glasto, and Bob Vylan will probably get a new record deal, more dates on their tour, and a few million more listeners from all this noise.
Sometimes I wonder what planet some people on here live on. The same arguments seem to rear their heads, as if these punk/rap groups give a fuck if they’ll spend some time in a cell.
I once had a car broken into and was told “what do you think we can do about that?” But it’s stunning to see an investigation into some chanting at a festival
Oh how times have changed… Those on the left who think „death to the IDF“ is OK have lost the moral authority they once had – because the left once knew words have meaning and there were things you don’t say. If „fuck the IDF“ had been said there wouldn’t have been an issue, some would have grumbled I’m sure but they’d have been told to wind their necks in.
I wonder how many of those on the left who are OK with „death to the IDF“ would be happy with a redneck band singing the same about gays, trans, non-whites etc.?
Edit: Please remember that Glastonbury was traditionally tied to the peace movement – CND and Greenpeace. Performers saying „stop the IDF“, „IDF out of Gaza“, „peace in Palestine“ or „end the occupation“ that’s fine, chanting „death to the IDF“ is very much against the ethos of Glastonbury.
Where do I email my support for the comments they made on stage?
People take things too literally these days (probably because it suits their agenda). Do they really think that the Glastonbury audience are going to take on the IDF after listening to Bob Vylan?
May the same treatment that Palestinians get while queuing for aid be inflicted on the IDF.