Close Menu
    Politics

    General im Ruhestand: Trump hat den Iran-Krieg „völlig schlecht gemanagt“.


    General im Ruhestand: Trump hat den Iran-Krieg „völlig schlecht gemanagt“.

    https://thehill.com/national-security/5788438-retired-general-slams-trump-iran/

    View 28 Comments

    28 Kommentare

    2. Beginning-Pace-1426 on

      Isn’t it incredible that since he took office we’ve always known he was a hair trigger pull away from *some* sort of ridiculous escalation of conflict? Weirdly, I wasn’t expecting us to go back to the middle east, but that should have been obvious.

    3. theguy1336 on

      The levels of insanity kinda remind me of those videos that show the size comparison of different planets and stars next to each other. You think you’re at total chaos, and then it zooms out and that was just a speck. The first term, to the first year of the second term, to this. The percentage likelihood of nukes being used by someone is now at two digits to me.

    4. Lonely_Noyaaa on

      Every military expert warned Trump this would happen but he ignored them because he thought he knew better.

    5. monkeywithgun on

      ‚Pay no attention to the man behind the Epstein files.‘

      It’s ‚mismanaged‘ because its born of desperation.

    6. WallNumerous3230 on

      I know they won’t do it… but congress really needs to hold an emergency session/vote on war powers and remove them from Dementia Don. If he doesn’t capitulate, impeach.

      Again, I said I know they won’t. But they should. This is the moment those checks were designed for.

      Trump is getting backed into a corner, and I would not put it past him to drop a nuke. The war is unpopular domestically. The war is unpopular, and being rebuked internationally by allies. Trump’s incompetent cabinet and Bibi grossly underestimated Iran, and they will be the winners from this, as the gulf states will demand US troops are removed once this is done for their security. China will displace the US power projection in the mideast, and will likely get the gulf states to destroy the petrodollar system, economically crushing the USA.

      This incompetent administration just learned the hard way why 7 former presidents over nearly half a decade didn’t do this.

      If only someone could have warned and advised him to not do this. /s

      The USA is so cooked now, no matter what. Thanks to this buffoon of a president and his administration.

    8. Firm_Argument9124 on

      The president’s that might have been competent to pull this off are also smart enough to not risk it. 

    9. berlin_got_blurry on

      Not many people are pointing out too that while this war is allegedly a joint operation with US and Israel, it is very much disjointed. Israel opened up a front in South Lebanon and they haven’t been quick to Trump’s defense by any means with the Hormuz crisis. They haven’t done anything to offer to help at all

    10. Hot_Ambition_6457 on

      Republican leadership is taking the most theorycrafted, war gamed, think-tank inspired conflict in all of American history and somehow still fumbling it into a global loss.

      The US Military has done wargames on the Gulf Iran conflict nonstop for 30 years. Its a problem the most decorated warlords ever have laid strategies out for, because of all the nuances in the region.

      Trump said „nah all those Military leaders before ne got it wrong“ and then fell for the exact trap the US has been countermeasuring since we got our hostages back.

      Its ego. He genuinely thinks he is a billionaire genius who can accomplish things with zero effort. Because since his birth he has been surrounded by „yes men“ who simply do the hard thing outside of his view and then give him credit.

      Lemme give you a few examples. He didnt found Trump Steaks, Trump Vodka, Trump Casinos, Trump Magazine etc. He just purchased existing businesses and put his name on them.

      Turns out ranching for high quality steak is very difficult. Sohe just purchased a succesful meat ranch and then took credit for it until it bankrupted. 

    11. FootballWise1426 on

      We attack Iran.
      Iran attacks the Middle East and cuts off oil supply.
      Gas prices rise rapidly.
      We allow Russia to bypass sanctions, hugely profiting off increased prices.. allowing them to not only sustain their war against Ukraine, but also support Iran.
      Iran, sustained, continues to fight back. 
      We have entered an escalation trap which will result in dead American servicemembers, dead civilians, protracted endangerment of Americans abroad, increased risk of coordinated and stochastic terrorism worldwide, acceleration of dedollarization of the oil market, global inflation, collapse of alliances… the list goes on.

      “All the past administrations wanted to do this!” Yeah, and they tabletop war gamed it and explored every possibility and the experts showed that the window for a fully successful mission was so narrow as to be practically impossible, partially successful outcomes were unlikely, and all of the alternative outcomes presented devastating risk and results.

      You can’t have a government of sycophants and yes men. You can still effectively lead with a circle of handpicked buddies and donors as all past presidents have but the dismantlement of traditionally apolitical government agency leadership over the last year has been more devastating than many realize. When you fire dedicated public servants and servicemembers for the sin of misalignment of party positions or the crime of holding anything less than total agreement, you remove guardrails and warning beeps and red flags that prevent the utter collapse of a nation. 

    13. morbob on

      Since when has trump managed anything properly?
      What 6-7 bankruptcies before his presidency?
      Guy is an idiot.

    14. nasorrty346tfrgser on

      The biggest reason is because he doesn’t have a clear objective on the top level. And then we have cleaned out a lot of experienced military officers in the mid level because of this political climate.

      Luckily we still have a very strong military on the lower level with tons of well trained services members. If not we have already lost

    17. justhavingfunMT on

      Over the last year, plus, can you tell me what he has properly managed? Better question yet, what has he not attempted to destroy?

    21. Syrairc on

      Hope Hegseth is getting ready for his ’new role‘ in some made up department.

    22. Tapprunner on

      The likelihood of Trump getting desperate and dropping a nuke can’t be any lower than 50/50 at this point.

    23. DaraParsavand on

      It’s always the retired generals. I know people depend on pensions but isn’t there anyone out there willing to do what lt gen Gregory Newbold was willing to do before the Iraq war? Imagine if all the generals resigned or just refused illegal orders.

    27. dhslax88 on

      As a non-military person, and a non-general, I can confirm that Trump has completely mismanaged everything.

    28. RIP_Greedo on

      He’s usually known for his fastidious planning and smart execution, so this is a real surprise.

    Leave A Reply